FranceLégifrance
€1m late-payment fine stands; French payment periods EU-compatible
The Conseil d'État upheld a €1m DGCCRF fine for 2018 late payments: French payment periods are EU-compatible, the invoice-issue date is the lawful yardstick, and supplier delays are no defence.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 30 September 2026
Industry: Across industries
A road-construction company that paid its suppliers late in 2018 owes a one-million-euro administrative fineLegifrance, and the notice of the sanction stays published on the DGCCRF website for twelve months. The Conseil d'État (9ème et 10ème chambres réunies, 30 September 2026, n° 505312) rejected the pourvoi of Eiffage Route Centre Est
Legifrance against the Lyon appeal court's judgment of 17 April 2025, which had upheld the 25 June 2022 sanction decision of the Auvergne-Rhône-Alpes DREETS director covering operations from 1 January to 31 December 2018.
The payment periods the company breached are those of article L. 441-6-I of the code de commerce in its 2018 wordingLegifrance, applicable until 26 April 2019 and since recodified by the ordonnance of 24 April 2019 as article L. 441-10: thirty days from receipt of the goods or performance of the service by default, sixty days from the invoice-issue date where the parties agree, or forty-five days end-of-month from the invoice-issue date where expressly stipulated without manifest abuse of the creditor
Legifrance. Periodic invoices within the meaning of 3 of I of article 289 of the code général des impôts carry a forty-five-day limit from issue.
These French periods are compatible with the Late Payment Directive 2011/7/EU.Legifrance They rebalance commercial relations in favour of creditors whose cash flow suffers from late payment, which article 12 of the directive expressly allows Member States to do
Legifrance, and the directive pursues no payment-period unification objective that the French rules could breach. Taking the invoice-issue date as the starting point does not offend the EU general principle of legal certainty: the seller must issue the invoice upon sale or performance and the buyer must claim it (article L. 441-3, now L. 441-9), and the invoice must bear its issue date under article 242 nonies A of Annex II to the code général des impôts. A contemplated Commission draft regulation that might impose invoice receipt as the starting point is without incidence, and with no serious difficulty of EU-law interpretation there was nothing to refer to the Court of Justice.
On the sanction, periodic invoices are not a separate type de délai légal within the meaning of the DGCCRF fining guidelines of 2 December 2021, so the administration owed the company no separately computed amount for them — a ground the Conseil d'État substituted for the appeal court's reasoning, curing it on that point. Otherwise the fine was sufficiently reasoned by reference to the share of late invoices, the scale of the overruns, the volume of business, the number of suppliers affected and the company's situation, with no duty to disclose the arithmetic formula of the penalty.
On quantum, standard-regime invoices showed 41.1% paid late with a 31.82-day weighted average overrun on 35,128,847 euros billed, while invoices under the transport-sector exception showed 72.9% paid late with a 29.71-day average on 15,472,533 euros billed. Late transmission of invoices by the suppliers does not exonerate the debtor, the argument that the company drew no cash-flow gain from the delays was inopérant, and the sanction was individualised and proportionate. The 6,000-euro claim under article L. 761-1 of the code de justice administrative fails with the appeal.
For B2B compliance, the invoice-issue date remains the lawful yardstickLegifrance, supplier-side delays are no defence, and seven-figure fines calibrated on late-invoice shares and overrun days survive proportionality review.
Legal basis: Conseil d'État, 9ème et 10ème chambres réunies, 30/09/2026, n° 505312 (ECLI:FR:CECHR:2026:505312.20260930); code de commerce, articles L. 441-6-I (2018 wording), L. 441-10, L. 441-16, L. 441-3 and L. 441-9; directive 2011/7/UE, articles 3 and 12; DGCCRF lignes directrices du 2 décembre 2021.
Measure supplier payment time from the invoice-issue date and document overrun exposure before any DGCCRF inspection.