United KingdomCase Law
Koza Ltd wound up on just and equitable ground after nine-year deadlock
The High Court granted summary judgment winding up Koza Ltd at the suit of its 100% ordinary shareholder, holding the director's refusal to implement Article 4 wind-down resolutions left no workable alternative.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 6 October 2026
Industry: Across industries
The High Court has ordered the just and equitable winding up of Koza Ltd
Nationalarchives on the petition of its 100% ordinary shareholder, Türk Altin İşletmeleri A.Ş
Nationalarchives, granting summary judgment and refusing the company's sole director, Hamdi Akin Ipek
Nationalarchives, permission to serve a proposed unfair prejudice petition on Türk Altin out of the jurisdiction
Nationalarchives. Mr Justice Thompsell handed the judgment down on 6 October 2026 after a June hearing; the control battle running since 2016 has generated 27 court applications, 18 High Court hearings, four Court of Appeal hearings and a trip to the Supreme Court.
Koza Ltd, an English company capitalised with £60 million from Türk Altin, has been shut out of control at board level for over nine years
Nationalarchives: Türk Altin holds all the ordinary shares carrying material economic rights
Nationalarchives, while Mr Ipek, the sole director, holds a single A ordinary share with no dividend rights and only £1 on a winding up, but with veto rights over board changes
Nationalarchives and over any resolution to wind the company up
Nationalarchives.
The court's reasoning ran through Article 4 of the Model Articles, the shareholders' reserve powerLegislation, which provides that the shareholders may by special resolution direct the directors to take, or refrain from taking, specified action
Legislation. Türk Altin had passed a series of Article 4 special resolutions
Nationalarchives directing the wind-down of the company's mining projects
Nationalarchives and the return of capital
Nationalarchives, which Mr Ipek refused to obey on the ground that compliance would breach his directors' duties
Nationalarchives. Counsel for Türk Altin argued for five propositions, and the court synthesised the arguments into six: shareholders are generally entitled to vote their shares in their own interests
Nationalarchives; there is no freestanding best-interests-of-the-company test for such resolutions, only a control based on minority oppression or illegality
Nationalarchives; a majority may not pass a resolution to the specific detriment of another body of shareholders or the specific advantage of the majority, save as justified by reference to the interests of the company as a whole
Nationalarchives; a resolution fails if a minority-oppression challenge against it succeeds
Nationalarchives; and, crucially, the direction of a valid special resolution falls within the director's section 171 duty to act in accordance with the company's constitution
Nationalarchives, so a director cannot refuse it on fiduciary-duty grounds
Nationalarchives. The court left the Part 8 claim for a declaration on the validity of the special resolutions undetermined, neither granted nor dismissed
Nationalarchives, once summary judgment on the petition made it unnecessary; it nevertheless held that Mr Ipek could not be criticised for failing to implement the EPA Resolutions as they stood, because the royalty stream diverted to Türk Altin made them unlawful as an unsanctioned distribution unless cured.
Mr Ipek applied for permission to serve a proposed unfair prejudice petition on Türk Altin out of the jurisdiction
Nationalarchives, alleging the special resolutions devalued the company, usurped his management and forced a breach of duty. It was held to have no reasonable prospect of success
Nationalarchives: a majority shareholder may vote its shares in its own interest
Nationalarchives and realise the company's assets, and once a just and equitable winding up is ordered Mr Ipek has no entitlement beyond his £1
Nationalarchives. There was no serious issue to be tried
Nationalarchives, so permission to serve out was refused.
The legal basis is the just-and-equitable winding-up jurisdiction alongside the section 171 duty to act within powers and the section 172 duty to promote the success of the company in the Companies Act 2006, and Article 4 of the Model Articles for private companies limited by shares in the Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008.
If you advise on shareholder deadlocks, cite Re Koza Ltd [2026] EWHC 2528 (BP) for the point that a sole director cannot defeat a just-and-equitable petition by refusing Article 4 wind-down resolutions on fiduciary-duty grounds.