European UnionEUR-Lex
EU court bars restatement rule for loss-making dividend recipients
Sweden cannot make withholding-tax refunds for loss-making non-residents conditional on restating their results — or their whole group's — under Swedish tax rules.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 17 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A source Member State cannot force a loss-making non-resident company to prove its losses by systematically restating its accounts under the source State's tax rules before refunding dividend withholding tax.Europa In a Grand Chamber judgment of 17 November 2026
Europa the Court of Justice held that such a practice restricts the free movement of capital under Article 63 TFEU
Europa, including where the company belongs to a group under consolidated taxation in its home State
Europa.
The case concerns Société GénéraleEuropa, a French company
Europa in a French consolidated tax group
Europa, which received dividends from Swedish companies in 2012 and paid Swedish withholding tax at source. It sought a refund, arguing that as a loss-making company it was in the same position as a loss-making Swedish company
Europa, which pays no dividend tax while it remains loss-making
Europa. The Swedish Tax Authority refused because the losses had not been computed under Swedish tax rules
Europa, and the Administrative Court in Falun upheld that refusal even though French tax returns showed significant losses for the company and its group.
The Court confirmed that resident and non-resident dividend recipients are in objectively comparable situations once the source State taxes both.Europa Ability to pay is assessed under each company's own home-State rules
Europa: a restatement under foreign rules tests only a hypothetical situation
Europa, and differences between national tax systems are the normal consequence of unharmonised direct taxation.
None of Sweden's justifications survived.Europa The balanced-allocation-of-taxing-powers argument fails for the same reasons as in the earlier Sofina and Credit Suisse Securities judgments, and cohesion of the tax system fails for want of a direct link between the advantage and a specific offsetting levy
Europa. On fraud prevention, the Court accepted that authorities may demand the evidence they need and may use mutual assistance to check it, but a blanket restatement duty rests on generalised suspicion of fraud
Europa, imposes a considerable administrative burden, and goes beyond what is necessary
Europa.
The same applies to groups: Sweden cannot require the whole French consolidated result to be recalculated, whether under Swedish tax rules generally or recast under Sweden's intra-group transfer rulesEuropa, which do not replicate consolidation
Europa. Taxpayers must still be able to show, clearly and precisely, that the refund conditions are met and that they were not artificially created.
Legal basis is the Grand Chamber judgment of 17 November 2026 in Case C-241/25, Société Générale v Skatteverket, interpreting Article 63 TFEU.
If you advise loss-making non-resident dividend recipients, claim withholding-tax refunds with home-State loss evidence that shows the conditions clearly and precisely, and challenge any demand to restate results under source-State rules.