United KingdomGOV.UK
HMRC pins CTSA discovery determinations to the overstated period
The determination is for the accounting period of the overstatement, needs a return for that period, and an assessment follows only where that period bears extra tax.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 16 November 2026
A discovery determination is the counterpart to a discovery assessment. Determinations are the tool where a discovery concerns a reduction of overstated losses or overclaimed or overstated relief that leads, or may lead, to additional tax for a different period from the one the discovery relates to, or for a different company. The rewritten manual now anchors the instrument: the discovery determination is for the accounting period in which the loss or relief is overstated or overclaimedGOV.
That anchoring tightens two neighbouring rules. A determination can only be made where the company has already delivered a return, and the return must now be for the accounting period the determination will relate to — not just any delivered returnGOV. And a discovery assessment is only appropriate where the discovery leads to additional tax liability on the company for that same accounting period. The companion assessing guidance puts the same divide in plainer terms: a determination addresses an amount incorrectly stated in a return that may affect another period or another company
GOV, while an assessment follows only where the period itself bears the extra tax
GOV.
A determination is rarely the end of the matter. Once issued, it may require a further assessment or determination for another accounting period of the same company, or for another company, to give the original determination effect — for example withdrawing consent to surrendered group relief and recovering the excessive relief from the claimant. Any follow-on must be made within the relevant time limit. Paragraph 42(2) lifts the paragraph 43 and 44 restrictions for a determination that simply gives effect to a determination made on another company's return, and paragraph 42(2A) does the same where the company received a notice after completed enquiries under section 184G or 184H of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 or section 81(2) of the Taxation (International and Other Provisions) Act 2010.
The rewrite preserves the boundary with revenue determinations: a discovery determination under paragraph 41(2) needs a delivered returnGOV, while a revenue determination under paragraph 36 or 37 needs the opposite — no return delivered, or only partial compliance with a notice to deliver. Determinations share the assessing conditions and time limits of discovery assessments, signposted at EM3231 and EM3213, and objections to non-compliance with the restriction paragraphs can only be raised on appeal against the determination itself.
The rules sit in paragraphs 41 to 45 of Schedule 18 to the Finance Act 1998, which define the discovery assessment, the discovery determination, the careless-or-deliberate and information-made-available gateways and the generally-prevailing-practice shield.
Where a CTSA discovery concerns overstated losses or relief, direct the determination at the period of overstatement, confirm a return exists for that period, and challenge any assessment that reaches beyond it.