FranceLégifrance
CNIL fines life insurer 5 million euros over password storage
Anonymised from publication, the life insurer kept 1.8 million passwords in clear and contact data for 13 years; remediation spared it an injunction but not the fine.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 18 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
The CNIL's formation restreinte imposed a 5,000,000 euro administrative fineLegifrance
Legifrance on an anonymised life-insurance company
Legifrance for breaching the security duty in Article 32 of the GDPR
Legifrance and the storage-limitation rule in Article 5(1)(e)
Legifrance. The decision, Délibération SAN-2026-016
Legifrance of 12 November 2026
Legifrance, is published on the CNIL site and Légifrance without naming the company. No compliance injunction was ordered
Legifrance because the company had remediated every breach during the proceedings
Legifrance; the breaches remain established for the past.
On password storage, the company kept more than 1.8 million customer access passwords in clear text in its customer-login data tableLegifrance, with 730,289 of them also in clear in a logging table
Legifrance. After the May 2024 inspection
Legifrance it first applied an obsolete unsalted ora_hash function
Legifrance, and only on 25 April 2026, after the sanction report, moved to a state-of-the-art hash with salt
Legifrance. The restricted panel holds that keeping passwords readable by anyone with database access, for almost two years after the inspection
Legifrance, failed to ensure security and confidentiality
Legifrance, whether or not the vulnerability was exploited. The rapporteur dropped the allegation that health data were reachable this way; full bank account numbers entered by customers in a contact form were present in a separate table but not reachable with the login password.
On access management, a generic application account shared by the eight members of one teamLegifrance gave access to a database holding all 1.3 million customers with life policies in force
Legifrance, with no reliable authentication or traceability of who accessed what
Legifrance. A shared administrator password for the tool used to view every database table was also in use on the inspection day
Legifrance. Nominal individual accounts were created in November 2025 and the administrator account was deactivated on 22 April 2026, but until June 2026 the company could not prove the shared accesses had ended
Legifrance.
On retention, a customer contact-form table held every mandatory field, message and attachment since November 2010Legifrance, the oldest message dating to 27 November 2010, more than thirteen years before the inspection, although the form was archived as a PDF once handled. A connection-logging table tracing each login kept customer identifiers and passwords for up to 21 years
Legifrance, including entries from 3 February 2003 and 8,628 passwords kept since 11 July 2019
Legifrance, against the company's own one-year policy
Legifrance. Since 10 July 2024 the company deletes contact-form history after one month and purges logs older than twelve months on a monthly rolling basis.
For the fine, the panel treated the mutual group and the company as a single economic undertaking in the competition-law senseLegifrance, following the Court of Justice's Deutsche Wohnen case law, and used the group's gross written premiums (primes brutes émises) for 2025 as the base
Legifrance, rejecting the IFRS 17 insurance-revenue measure. The rapporteur had first proposed 9 million euros, then 7 million; the panel set 5 million
Legifrance having regard to the number of people affected, negligence, cooperation and remediation. The decision may be appealed to the Conseil d'État
Legifrance within two months of notification
Legifrance.
The legal basis is Délibération SAN-2026-016 of the CNIL of 12 November 2026, applying Articles 5(1)(e), 32 and 83 of Regulation (EU) 2016/679Legifrance and Article 20-IV of loi n° 78-17 of 6 January 1978
Legifrance.
Enforce salted slow-hash password storage, individual database accounts and one-month contact-form plus twelve-month rolling log retention.