European UnionEUR-Lex
EU court upholds €822,512 CEF recovery in time-records case
A post-audit exclusivity declaration signed years later cannot rescue personnel costs, and ex post procurement explanations cannot prove best value for money, the General Court held.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 18 November 2026
Public Sector & EconomyLegal & Corporate
Industry: Across industries
The General Court dismissedEuropa on 18 November 2026, in case T-380/25, a challenge by Spanish translation-services company Pangeanic B I Europa, SL to a recovery of EUR 822,511.98
Europa claimed by the European Health and Digital Executive Agency (HaDEA) under three Connecting Europe Facility (CEF) telecommunications grant agreements. The debit note stands
Europa, and the company must pay the costs.
The grants, concluded with the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency (now HaDEA) for machine-translation and chatbot projects running from September 2017 to February 2020, reimbursed 75% of eligible costs. A 2021-commissioned external audit found the time-recording system weak and rejected all personnel costs, and rejected subcontracting costs under the second and third agreements because the procurement was not documented well enough to show best value for money. HaDEA sent a pre-information letter on 5 April 2024, its final position on 26 September 2024, and debit note No 3242412359 for EUR 822,511.98 on 25 October 2024.
On personnel costs, the Court held that the exclusive-work exception in point 2.3 of the Annex to Commission Decision C(2016) 478 final of 3 February 2016 excuses time records only if the beneficiary signs a declaration confirming exclusive work during implementation or at the latest immediately afterwards, in the same financial yearEuropa. Although the provision uses the present perfect ("have worked"), context and purpose — contemporaneous, supervisor-approved monthly records feeding the unit-cost calculation — require the declaration to be contemporaneous with the work
Europa. Pangeanic's chief executive declaration of 14 December 2022, more than two years after the last action ended and produced during the audit after the weaknesses were flagged, could not prove anything
Europa: it was unverifiable, arrived after payment of the balance when Article II.27.1 audit rights apply, and was internally inconsistent, naming one employee as exclusive to all three overlapping actions and seven as exclusive to two. Costs not shown to be verifiable in the records must be recovered
Europa, and technical success of the projects does not create a payment right
Europa.
On subcontracting, the Court held that Article II.9.1's best-value-for-money rule also requires transparency, competition and equal treatment of tenderersEuropa, derived from the sound-financial-management principle in Articles 310(5) and 317 TFEU and Article 33 of Regulation (EU, Euratom) 2018/1046. Proof must be contemporaneous
Europa: an undated explanation drafted for the proceedings, stating only price and proximity without technical specifications, criterion weightings or fit with the call
Europa, plus three bare tenders, cannot show the winning tender was best value or the procedure fair
Europa. The low value of the contract is no excuse
Europa, and the third-agreement subcontracts, one with a supplier employing the beneficiary's own staff member and one with the beneficiary's own division, were conceded as ineligible
Europa.
Procedurally, the late final audit report — due 60 days after the 15 December 2022 observations, sent 11 October 2023 — had no consequence absent demonstrated harm, the right to be heard was satisfied through repeated rounds of comments, and new pleas, evidence and staff-allocation matrices raised only at the reply stage were inadmissible under Articles 76(d), 84 and 85 of the Rules of Procedure.
Legal basis is Articles 272, 310(5) and 317 TFEU, Regulation (EU, Euratom) 2018/1046, Article 33, Commission Decision C(2016) 478 final, and the CEF grant general conditions, Articles II.9.1, II.19.1, II.19.2(a), II.20.5 and II.27.
Sign exclusive-work declarations during implementation or the same financial year, and document procurement criteria, weighting and evaluation at award time — ex post paperwork will not survive a HaDEA audit.