SwedenDomstol Rattspraxis
HVB placements are not always similar contracts under LOU aggregation rules
Högsta förvaltningsdomstolen holds interchangeability decides; quashes lower courts and rejects a SEK 2 million fee against Huddinge kommun.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 18 November 2026
Industry: General public administration activities
Municipalities must provide access to hem för vård eller boende (HVB), where individuals are placed voluntarily or in some cases by compulsion. The homes address different target groups, such as children or young people of a certain age and sex, people with substance abuse problems, or families, and provide different care or treatment for addiction, criminality or psychosocial problems. Each placement is adapted to the individual's needs, and private operators need a permit specifying the target group, conditions and number of residents.
Huddinge kommun made several direct awards of individual HVB placements during 2022 and 2023Domstol. A direct award contracts for services without prior advertisement and tendering. For services in Annex 2, which include social services, it is permitted where the contract value stays below the threshold
Domstol, which was 7,802,550 kronor at the relevant time
Domstol. For contracts that recur regularly, the value is in principle the actual total of all similar contracts procured in the preceding twelve months, or the estimated total for the coming twelve months
Domstol, so that authorities cannot split a recurring need to stay below the threshold
Domstol. An unlawful direct award can trigger an upphandlingsskadeavgift, then at least 10,000 kronor and at most 10,000,000 kronor, capped at ten per cent of the procurement value.
Konkurrensverket sought a 2,000,000 kronor feeDomstol for one placement contract worth 345,800 kronor
Domstol, standing alone below the threshold
Domstol. It argued the value had to include every direct HVB award for children and young people up to 20 years the municipality had made in the preceding twelve months, because they were similar contracts, producing a total of just under 25,000,000 kronor
Domstol. Förvaltningsrätten accepted that all the HVB placements were similar by character
Domstol, and Kammarrätten agreed
Domstol.
Högsta förvaltningsdomstolen rejects that automatic aggregationDomstol. It accepts tangible overarching similarities: the same object, the same main social-services category, often shared CPV codes, HVB as accommodation defined and delimited in national legislation, and a common purpose of meeting the municipality's statutory duty of care
Domstol. But that is not enough
Domstol. The decisive question is whether the placements are interchangeable
Domstol, meaning whether a placement in one home could have been replaced by a placement in the other
Domstol. Factors include whether the contracts, viewed through the respective operating permits, principally concern the same target group and the same type of care or treatment
Domstol. Only contracts similar after that examination are aggregated
Domstol.
The court points to two supporting considerations. Social services such as HVB have limited cross-border interest and are provided in settings that vary widely between Member States, which is why a higher direct-award threshold appliesDomstol; routinely adding together every HVB procurement over twelve months would often defeat that higher limit
Domstol. Municipalities also generally cannot meet every need through framework agreements, and the HVB market is constrained because permits are relatively specific about the permitted activity.
Applied here, aggregation of all awards for children and young people up to 20 years was therefore wrong in law without an individualised examinationDomstol. Material Konkurrensverket first submitted to Högsta förvaltningsdomstolen about the period's awards required special reasons to be considered in a leave-to-appeal case
Domstol, and the court found none
Domstol, so it disregarded that material
Domstol. With no other investigation of the specific contracts, there was no basis to hold them similar
Domstol. The court granted leave in the remainder of the case
Domstol, set aside both lower rulings
Domstol and rejected the fee application
Domstol.
Legal basis is 5 kap. 11 §, 19 a kap. 2 § and 21 kap. lagen (2016:1145) om offentlig upphandlingDomstol, implementing article 5.11 of Directive 2014/24/EU.
Before aggregating HVB contract values over a twelve-month period, test whether the placements are interchangeable in target group and care type under their permits, and document that assessment.