United KingdomGOV.UK
Taxpayers gain second route to rebut extended-time assessments
EM3259 now lets the taxpayer defeat an ETL assessment by showing the behaviour did not cause the loss, not only that it did not happen; case owners must still gather all facts.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 17 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
Taxpayers facing an extended time limit assessment can now defeat it in either of two ways: by showing that the relevant behaviour did not occur, or by showing that the behaviour did not bring about the loss of taxGOV. The Enquiry Manual page on the onus of proof for ETL assessments (EM3259) previously gave the taxpayer only the first route
GOV. The added second limb matters because the behaviour and its causation of the loss are separate points: the manual's opening passage covers losses brought about carelessly or deliberately by the taxpayer or a person acting on their behalf, and points case owners to EM3232 on acting on behalf and causation for the behaviour-based time limit conditions.
The structure of the burden is otherwise unchanged. HMRC bears the initial burden of establishing a prima facie case that a relevant condition is met; once that is done, the assessment is presumed to be valid and the burden shifts to the taxpayer, who may now use either limbGOV. The neighbouring examples guidance proceeds on the basis that, in the examples it gives, one of the conditions in section 29(3) (or Paragraph 42) must be met before a discovery assessment is made.
The instruction on fact-finding is otherwise unchanged. Both the old and the new version say that reaching the evidential threshold does not mean case owners should stop: they should always seek to gather all relevant facts so that the most accurate decision can be made on whether the condition is met. The edit removes the words prima facie from the threshold sentence, so the manual now speaks of sufficient evidence to make a case rather than a prima facie case.
For advisers, the new second limb is the point to plead. Where the behaviour is admitted or uncontestable, the assessment can still be challenged on the ground that the loss of tax was not brought about by that behaviourGOV, drawing on the EM3232 causation material the manual itself cross-refers. For HMRC case owners, the page remains a reminder that a file closed at the threshold is not enough: the decision on the condition must rest on all relevant facts.
Where the behaviour is conceded, challenge the ETL assessment on causation: show the behaviour did not bring about the loss of tax.