United KingdomGOV.UK
Written disclosures must flag relevance to block discovery
EM3233 item D now counts a written notification as made available only where it notifies the existence and relevance of the information to the situation discovered.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 17 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A protective letter to HMRC no longer counts as information made available merely because it was put in writing.GOV
GOV Item D of the information-made-available definition now covers only information the existence and relevance of which to the situation discovered is notified in writing to HMRC by the taxpayer or a person acting on their behalf.
GOV A written notification that discloses information without flagging what it is and why it matters to the insufficiency HMRC later discovers falls outside the category.
GOV
The first limb of item D is unchanged: information whose existence and relevance could reasonably be expected to be inferred from material in categories A to C still counts. Categories A to C are also unchanged: matter contained in a relevant return or accompanying accounts, statements or documents; matter in a relevant claim or its accompanying documents; and documents, accounts or particulars supplied in connection with an enquiry into relevant returns or claims. Relevant returns and claims are those for the year of assessment and each of the two immediately preceding years, or accounting periods for corporation tax self-assessment. To be made available, information must be provided by the end of the enquiry period, though information provided before the period began counts if it falls in a category.
The wording now tracks section 29(6)(d) of the Taxes Management Act 1970, which frames item D in exactly these terms: information the existence of which, and the relevance of which as regards the situation in section 29(1), could reasonably be expected to be inferred from paragraphs (a) to (c), or are notified in writing by the taxpayer to an officer. The manual change brings the internal guidance into line with the statute.
The surrounding test is unchanged. The condition protects taxpayers who make honest, complete and timely disclosure, testing whether the hypothetical officer — a person of general competence with a reasonable knowledge and understanding of the law, not any actual officer — could not reasonably have been expected to be aware of the section 29(1) situation when the enquiry period ceased. Awareness means awareness of an actual insufficiency: material that would merely have prompted more questions is not enough, though the greater the legal or factual complexity, the greater the disclosure required. Individual pieces of information need not each reveal the loss; a return for a relevant year counts even if it says nothing about the loss discovered. Where a return was submitted, only one of the assessing conditions needs to be met, so a conclusion that the made-available information was sufficient should prompt careful thought about whether the taxpayer carelessly or deliberately brought about the loss.
For advisers, the consequence is drafting discipline. A protective disclosure should state in the letter itself what the information is and why it is relevant to the potential insufficiency, rather than relying on HMRC to connect a bare enclosure to the issue. Best practice remains to compile a complete list of the information made available, which HMRC should itself be able to list, calling on the Specialist Technical Team via the TAA1 form where case teams struggle.
State in the disclosure letter itself what each enclosure is and why it matters to the potential insufficiency; do not rely on HMRC to connect a bare enclosure to the issue.