FinlandVero
Dutch STAK receipt swap taxed as share exchange, gain deferred
Look-through applies on both sides: Dutch transparency plus Finnish substance turns a STAK receipt swap into a 52 f § share exchange with deferred gain and non-deductible loss.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A Finnish holder of Dutch depositary receipts can exchange the underlying shares for the buyer's shares with no immediate tax on the gain, where the arrangement meets the statutory share-exchange conditions
Vero, even though the holder never directly owns the target shares.
The holder, applicant A, owned aktiedepåbevis in the Dutch vehicle STAK B. The receipts carried only the economic rights in a corresponding number of B-shares in C BV, which were owned by STAK B. STAK B was a Dutch legal person formed by agreement, with no share capital, no shares and no shareholders. Receipt holders had no controlling influence; control was exercised by its board, and a holder had no right to demand conversion into the underlying shares.
By the vehicle's articles, dividends and other distributions on the managed shares had to be passed on immediately to the receipt holders, with corresponding new receipts on bonus issues, new issues or restructurings.
For Dutch company income taxation, STAK B was not a separate taxable person
Vero. It was treated as a transparent flow-through entity
Vero, so income and gains were taxed directly as income of the receipt holders. It could not be a treaty subject, and the restructuring was regarded in the Netherlands as a share exchange in which the receipt holders transferred shares
Vero.
The Central Tax Board looked through the vehicle on the Finnish side
Vero. Having regard to STAK B's legal characteristics, the applicant's economic rights and the Dutch tax treatment, income received through STAK B was taxed as the applicant's income as if received directly
Vero. When STAK B transferred the C BV shares, the applicant was therefore taxed as if the applicant had transferred them personally.
Before the restructuring, D BV held more than half of the votes in C BV. D BV acquired the remaining C BV shares from STAK B and the other shareholders for its own newly issued C-series shares. No cash was paid. After the exchange, the receipts for B-shares in C BV were cancelled and STAK B issued receipts for the new C-shares in D BV.
That pattern matched 52 § 2 mom. and 52 f § 1 mom. of lagen om beskattning av inkomst av näringsverksamhet
Vero. Neither that Act nor the corporate restructuring directive imposed any requirement on the legal form of a transferring shareholder in a share exchange
Vero. Taking Article 8.3 of the directive into account, the restructuring was treated as a share exchange within the meaning of 52 f § 1 mom
Vero.
The consequence is deferral. Gain on the exchange is not taxable income of the applicant
Vero, and loss is not deductible under 45 § 5 mom. of inkomstskattelagen
Vero. The acquisition cost carries overFinlex, so a later cash disposal is the point at which the economics are taxed.
The ruling binds only applicant A, for tax years 2026 and 2027, and it is marked as not yet final. Those facts - no controlling influence, no conversion right and no cash - are the basis on which the exchange was accepted as a share exchange.
Legal basis: 52 § 2 mom. and 52 f § 1 mom. of lagen om beskattning av inkomst av näringsverksamhet (360/1968), 45 § 1 and 5 mom. of inkomstskattelagen, and Articles 2(1)(e) and 8(3) of Council Directive 2009/133/EC as applied in the ruling.
If you advise a holder of Dutch STAK depositary receipts facing a share-for-share offer with no cash, test the arrangement against the 52 f § conditions and seek an advance ruling where the position is material.