FranceLégifrance
Heart attack at work presumed service-related, top court rules
The Lyon court asked whether the fatal shift was strenuous; it should have asked whether prior health was the exclusive cause. The ruling also holds imputability refusals are not pecuniary-only decisions.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 17 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A heart attack suffered at the workplace is presumed to be a service-related accidentLegifrance, and the court hearing the case must test that presumption by asking whether the official's prior state of health was the exclusive cause
Legifrance — not by asking whether the working day was unusually strenuous
Legifrance. The Conseil d'État so held
Legifrance on 17 November 2026
Legifrance in a case brought by the widow of a Combloux employee, an adjoint technique principal who died of a heart attack at work on 12 August 2014 after the mayor refused on 28 July 2015 to recognise the death as imputable au service
Legifrance. The tribunal administratif de Grenoble rejected her indemnity claim in November 2022 and the cour administrative d'appel de Lyon dismissed her appeal
Legifrance in November 2024; she sought cassation plus 3,000 euros under article L. 761-1 of the code de justice administrative.
The ruling restates the presumption now codified in article L. 822-18 of the code général de la fonction publiqueLegifrance: any accident suffered by an official, whatever its cause, in the time and place of service, in or on the occasion of the exercise of functions or an activity constituting their normal extension, is presumed service-related absent personal fault or another particular circumstance detaching it from service
Legifrance. The same rule applied before 2017 under article 57 of the 1984 statute. An accident means any event occurring on a definite date that produced an injury, whenever it appeared. For cardio-neurovascular accidents in particular, the official's prior health counts as a detaching circumstance only where it was the exclusive cause of the accident.
Legifrance
The Lyon court had reasoned that the deceased showed no cardiac history — only hypertension with hypercholesterolaemia — that the attack came at the start of the working day, and that he had performed no unusual task and no intense effort capable of triggering cardiac arrest, concluding the mayor was right to refuse imputability. That reasoning inverted the test: the accident having occurred in the time and place of service, the court was required to examine whether the prior state of health was the exclusive cause of the accidentLegifrance, and it decided without that examination
Legifrance. The Conseil d'État annulled the appellate ruling on that error of law
Legifrance and remanded the case to the Lyon court
Legifrance.
The decision also settles an admissibility point that public employers will invoke. A claim for indemnity founded solely on the illegality of a decision with an exclusively pecuniary object is inadmissible once that decision has become final with all its inseparable pecuniary consequencesLegifrance — a rule the ruling states before applying it. But a refusal to recognise imputability au service is not a decision with an exclusively pecuniary object, even where the official has died
Legifrance. The commune of Combloux therefore could not have its alternative ground substituted for the quashed reasoning, and the widow's indemnity action, seeking 371,341.32 euros and subsidiarily 294,680.97 euros, survives to be re-examined on remand.
On costs, the commune pays the widow 3,000 euros under article L. 761-1, and its own 4,000-euro claim under the same article fails because the widow is not the losing party. Public-body legal services should audit pending imputability refusals for the two corrections: test cardiac and similar cases through the exclusive-cause lens, and handle imputability refusals as decisions that remain open to indemnity challenge rather than as pecuniary-only decisionsLegifrance. Basis: Conseil d'État, 3rd and 8th chambers combined, 17 November 2026, No. 500933, applying article 57 of the law of 26 January 1984, article L. 822-18 of the code général de la fonction publique and article L. 761-1 of the code de justice administrative.
Audit pending imputability-au-service refusals against the exclusive-cause test and treat them as open to indemnity challenge, not as final pecuniary decisions.