GermanyWirtschaftsprüferkammer
WPK fines auditor €5,000 over audits without register entry
WPK publishes Rüge and €5,000 Geldbuße over seven statutory audits without register entry; auditor cites disputed succession after audit-business spin-off.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Accounting, bookkeeping and auditing activities; tax consultancy
The Wirtschaftsprüferkammer (WPK) has published enforcement measure No. 28 for 2026WPK, dated 18 November 2026
WPK: a Rüge and a Geldbuße of 5,000 EUR
WPK against Wirtschaftsprüferin Ramona Bierl
WPK, acting for aucuron GmbH Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft
WPK. The activity concerned is the conduct of statutory audits of annual accounts under §§ 316 ff. Handelsgesetzbuch (HGB)
WPK. WPK found a lack of Prüfungsberechtigung under § 319 Abs. 1 Satz 3 HGB
WPK.
In seven cases statutory annual audits were conducted in the name of a WirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaftWPK without the required extract from the Berufsregister concerning the entry of the notification that the firm acts as statutory auditor
WPK, under §§ 38 Nr. 2 Buchstabe f in Verbindung mit 57a Abs. 1 Wirtschaftsprüferordnung (WPO). Wirtschaftsprüfer, vereidigte Buchprüfer and their firms must notify WPK when they first intend to conduct statutory audits under § 316 HGB
WPK; no new notification is needed for follow-up engagements.
WPin Bierl responded on 28 October 2026WPK under § 69 Abs. 1 Satz 4 WPO that the case rests on a disputed legal question not yet decided by a higher court
WPK. She respects the chamber's decision but maintains that she acted on a defensible reading of transformation and professional law
WPK and did not consciously disregard her professional duties.
Her account is that aucuron GmbH WPG took over the entire Wirtschaftsprüfung part of the business of another audit firm by AbspaltungWPK. Under §§ 123 Abs. 2 and 131 Abs. 1 Nr. 1 Umwandlungsgesetz (UmwG), all assets assigned to that part pass as a whole to the acquiring entity when the split takes effect
WPK. In her consistently stated view, that universal succession also carried the existing entry as Abschlussprüferin held by the transferring entity
WPK, so aucuron held the required Berufsregister entry
WPK and she, as Prokuristin, did not audit without the authorisation required by § 319 Abs. 1 Satz 3 HGB.
Only strictly personal rights stay outside universal succession, an absolute exception that as a rule only arises for rights granted expressly to a natural person. In her view the entry as statutory auditor is not such a right, and nothing in the WPO makes it one. The Berufsregister entry, with reference to §§ 57a Abs. 2 and 55b Abs. 2 Satz 2 WPO, serves quality control and attaches not to particular persons but to the adequacy and effectiveness of the quality-assurance system. Because the entire organisational structure moved over, the relevant structures and processes were unchanged. Confidence in independence, conscientiousness and impartiality attaches to the audit firm as such, not to a particular person. The entry is in the end purely declaratory, following the underlying legal position. Even treated as personal, the personnel conditions for its continuance were still met after the split, and since the whole part of the business moved, the entry could not remain with the transferor.
The proper conduct of the audits themselves was not at issue, only the register formality. Once it became known that the chamber takes a different view, she arranged for aucuron GmbH WPG to be entered without delay as a statutory auditorWPK, so the criticised state has been remedied.
Legal basis: WPO §§ 69 Abs. 1, 38 Nr. 2 Buchstabe f, 57a Abs. 1; HGB §§ 316 ff., 319 Abs. 1 Satz 3; Umwandlungsgesetz §§ 123 Abs. 2, 131 Abs. 1 Nr. 1 as invoked in the published response.
WPGs that took over an audit practice by spin-off should verify that their Anzeige as gesetzlicher Abschlussprüfer and Berufsregister entry are effective for the acquiring entity before conducting §316 HGB audits, and file a new Anzeige and obtain the register extract where in doubt.