United KingdomGOV.UK
CMA eases PMI report enforcement pending remedy review
The CMA provisionally moves to remove Parts 2 and 4 of the PMI Order 2015 and will not prioritise enforcement of the 1 February 2027 compliance reports; a final retain decision extends the deadline to 31 March 2027.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Non-life insurance · Activities of insurance agents and brokers
Private motor insurance providers get conditional relief on next year's compliance reportingGOV. On 12 August 2026 the Competition and Markets Authority published a provisional decision
GOV in its strategic review of 33 markets remedies
GOV, provisionally deciding to remove Part 2 of the Private Motor Insurance Market Investigation Order 2015
GOV. On 16 November 2026 it published a supplementary provisional decision
GOV, provisionally deciding to remove Part 4 of the Order as well
GOV.
Pending a final decision on the Order, the Authority has decided as an administrative priority to deprioritise enforcement action against providers who do not provide a compliance report to the CMA in respect of Parts 2 and 4 by the deadline of 1 February 2027.GOV The two possible endings are spelled out. If the final decision is to remove Parts 2 and 4, the requirement to provide compliance reports will no longer apply.
GOV If the final decision is to retain Parts 2 and 4, the deadline for compliance reports moves to 31 March 2027.
GOV
The deprioritisation is an enforcement posture, not a change in the lawGOV, and providers should not treat the filing duty as gone. The Authority expressly cautions that its position does not and cannot change the statutory obligations in sections 167(2) to (5) of the Enterprise Act 2002
GOV, and that providers should weigh those obligations when deciding their next steps on compliance statements. Those subsections impose a duty on any person to whom an enforcement order relates to comply with it, owe that duty to anyone who may be affected by a contravention, make breach actionable by a person who sustains loss or damage, and offer a defence of having taken all reasonable steps and exercised all due diligence. Separately, compliance is enforceable by the Authority through civil proceedings for an injunction or other appropriate relief, and the Authority may also impose penalties for failure to comply without reasonable excuse.
The Order itself remains in force until any final removal decision.GOV Made under the market investigation provisions of the 2002 Act following the private motor insurance market investigation, it bans agreements between price comparison websites and insurers that stop insurers from making their products available more cheaply on other online platforms, and requires better consumer information on the costs and benefits of no-claims bonus protection. Until now, PMI insurers and brokers had to submit an Annual PMI Compliance Statement by 1 February each year, via an online form with tables of average no-claims bonus discounts.
For in-house teams the prudent course is to prepare as if the duty survives while documenting the decision. Keep the 1 February 2027 date diaried, since it remains the nominal deadlineGOV and becomes 31 March 2027 only if the final decision retains the Parts
GOV; assemble the compliance material so it can be filed under either outcome; record why any filing is withheld, grounded in the published deprioritisation and the section 167 assessment rather than in an assumption that the duty has fallen away; and watch for the final decision, which either extinguishes the reporting requirement or sets the extended deadline. Broker-insurer businesses should continue to allocate reporting by the primary role of the business.
The reporting duties sit in the Private Motor Insurance Market Investigation Order 2015, made under Part 4 of the Enterprise Act 2002, with the underlying compliance duty in sections 167(2) to (5) of that Act.
Prepare the PMI compliance material for 1 February 2027, record any decision not to file against the published deprioritisation and section 167, and watch for the final decision setting 31 March 2027.