SwedenSkatteverket
Retailer denied SEK 20.4m lease-loss provision, penalty stands
Kammarrätten i Göteborg refused a SEK 20.4m lease-loss provision for 2021 and upheld the penalty: operating revenues and staff costs cannot turn leases into loss contracts.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 20 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A retail company's 20.4 million kronor provision for loss-making shop leasesSkatteverket was not deductible
Skatteverket, and the penalty for the incorrect return stands
Skatteverket. Kammarrätten i Göteborg dismissed the appeal
Skatteverket in its judgment of 6 October 2026 in case 195-26, affirming Förvaltningsrätten i Göteborg's judgment
Skatteverket of 13 November 2025 in cases 10330-24 and 10331-24, and refused compensation for litigation costs.
The company, anonymised in the judgment, applied Bokföringsnämndens allmänna råd BFNAR 2012:1 on annual accounts and treated each shop as an economically separable unit. It computed unavoidable costs of non-cancellable leases, net of expected operating benefits in the form of estimated gross profit, and booked a provision for förlustkontrakt for tax year 2021. Two expert opinions supported the method, and the company's former auditors had recommended it. The company argued that case law cited by Skatteverket concerned older accounting rules and a different situation, and that continuing to trade from the premises was the economically rational way to minimise lease-driven losses.
Both courts held that deduction of such provisions follows god redovisningssed absent special tax rulesSkatteverket, and that the provision here did not meet it
Skatteverket. Lease payments must be tested against costs and losses that are unavoidable and directly attributable to the lease itself
Skatteverket. Store sales revenues and future staff costs for running the shops belong to future operations, not to the lease contracts
Skatteverket, and netting them into the provision turns it into a provision for future operating losses
Skatteverket, for which BFNAR 2012:1 gives no room
Skatteverket. The courts pointed to the commentary on point 21.3, whose example of an operationell leasingavtal turned loss contract is an undertaking obliged to pay lease charges for an asset it no longer needs, and to the restrictive line in Kammarrätten i Stockholm's judgment of 12 June 2001 in case 517-1999 for unused rented premises. Here the premises were in use when the provisions were booked
Skatteverket, and nothing showed that accounting practice on this point had changed since that judgment
Skatteverket.
On skattetillägg, the courts found the company had given an oriktig uppgiftSkatteverket that understated final tax by a significant amount
Skatteverket for 2021, first detected on Skatteverket's investigation
Skatteverket. Merely enclosing the 2021 annual report, where the deduction appeared in note 30 without any tax adjustment, did not make it nearly excluded that the return would be accepted without further inquiry
Skatteverket, so Skatteverket's utredningsskyldighet was not triggered
Skatteverket (see HFD 2025 not. 35 and 37). The error was not a periodiseringsfel or equivalent under prop. 1991/92:43 p. 68 f.
Skatteverket: the provision had not been shown to be fully reversed before Skatteverket flagged it
Skatteverket — the 2022 reversal of 13,143,325 kronor cited by the company was adopted on 28 July 2023
Skatteverket during the ongoing audit — and the court kept the full rate
Skatteverket, rejecting the company's plea for the lower periodiseringsfel rate
Skatteverket. For the loss-provision penalty the courts saw no ground for full or partial befrielse
Skatteverket: the issue was not an excusably difficult assessment, the company gave no supporting disclosure despite calling the question difficult, and the penalty was proportionate to the error
Skatteverket. (The 75 per cent partial relief Skatteverket granted concerned only the SLP and car-leasing VAT items, not the loss provision
Skatteverket.)
Legal basis is god redovisningssed under BFNAR 2012:1 for avsättning för förlustkontrakt, 16 kap. 1 § inkomstskattelagen on deduction, and the skattetillägg rules on oriktig uppgift, utredningsskyldighet and periodiseringsfel applied in Kammarrätten i Göteborg mål nr 195-26.
Advisers to retail and lease-heavy companies should test each lease in isolation against unavoidable contract costs without operating revenues or staff, and file a supporting disclosure for uncertain loss provisions.