United KingdomGOV.UK
Tax-agent dishonest-conduct regime ends 31 March 2026
HMRC confirms dishonest-conduct agent rules cover conduct only up to 31 March 2026; sanctionable conduct under amended Schedule 38 applies to conduct happening from 1 April 2026.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Accounting, bookkeeping and auditing activities; tax consultancy
HMRC's disclosure-quality guidance for agent penalties now carries an explicit time boundary. The rules on dishonest conduct for tax agents apply only to conduct that happens up to 31 March 2026GOV. Under the amended Schedule 38 of the Finance Act 2012, sanctionable conduct applies to tax adviser conduct that happens from 1 April 2026.
The boundary sits at the top of the Compliance Handbook page on determining the quality of disclosure (CH184260). The rest of the page is substantively unchanged apart from trailing-whitespace typography: arriving at the quality of a disclosure still means weighing the three elements of telling, helping and giving access against their timing, nature and extent, alongside compliance with any file access notice issued in connection with the dishonest conduct. The penalty still has regard to all three elements after considering the person's representations and any evidence offering a different view of the disclosure, overlaps between the elements may be counted under more than one heading, and a person is not disadvantaged for withholding documents they consider privileged or covered by the other exclusions.
What changes is which regime that machinery belongs to. For conduct before 1 April 2026, HMRC can continue to charge penalties for dishonest conduct by tax agentsGOV. For conduct on or after 1 April 2026, only the sanctionable-conduct regime can ground a penalty
GOV. The commencement guidance confirms the cutover is about when the conduct occurred: a file access notice issued after 1 April 2026 may still request documents that existed before that date, for example to establish that someone was acting as a tax adviser when the relationship began earlier, so that HMRC can determine whether the sanctionable-conduct test is met.
The sanctionable-conduct test itself is intentional and narrow. A tax adviser engages in sanctionable conduct only if, in the course of acting as a tax adviser, they do something or omit to do something with the intention of bringing about a loss of tax revenueGOV. HMRC applies two questions — was the conduct in the course of acting as a tax adviser, and was it done with that subjective intention judged on the adviser's knowledge at the time — to the civil standard of balance of probabilities, with the burden on HMRC. No actual loss needs to have resulted. Advisers who take a credible view of what the law requires even where it differs from HMRC's view, who follow published HMRC guidance even if it proves legally wrong, who properly rely on a published extra-statutory concession, or who simply make mistakes while trying to do the right thing, are not engaging in sanctionable conduct.
For practitioners the boundary has filing-cabinet consequences. The disclosure-quality assessment in CH184260 now governs only the earlier periodGOV, while later conduct is tested for sanctionable intent
GOV. Preserve engagement records spanning the cutover, since pre-April documents can still be compelled under a post-April file access notice. And disclosure behaviour still moves penalties under both regimes, so cooperate early, make representations with evidence, and assert privilege properly rather than by silence.
The regime rests on Schedule 38 to the Finance Act 2012GOV as amended by section 250 and Schedule 22 of the Finance Act 2026
GOV.
For adviser conduct around 1 April 2026, confirm whether the dishonest-conduct or sanctionable-conduct rules apply, and preserve engagement records spanning the cutover.
Sources
- Dishonest tax agents: penalty for dishonest conduct: disclosure: determining the quality
- Sanctionable conduct by tax advisers: Commencement date
- Sanctionable conduct by tax advisers: determining sanctionable conduct: what is sanctionable conduct?
- How HMRC deals with tax adviser sanctionable conduct
- Sanctionable conduct by tax advisers: penalty for sanctionable conduct: disclosure overview
- Sanctionable conduct by tax advisers: Legislation