InternationalOECD
OECD MAP reviews: Germany on target, Austria, Malta and US slow
Cycle 1 peer reviews put Ireland and Luxembourg well inside the 24-month MAP target and Germany just inside it, while Austria, Malta and the United States close cases far slower.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
The OECD Inclusive Framework approved six more Cycle 1 full peer reviews under the BEPS Action 14 minimum standard
Oecd on 1 September 2025
Oecd, covering Austria, Germany, Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta and the United States
Oecd. Together they administered about 2,700 mutual agreement procedure (MAP) cases
Oecd at the end of 2023
Oecd, with Germany (1,332 cases)
Oecd and the United States (665)
Oecd accounting for almost three-quarters of the batch
Oecd.
Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta and the United States meet almost all elements of the standard
Oecd
Oecd
Oecd
Oecd, Austria meets most of them
Oecd and Germany meets the majority
Oecd. Ireland closed cases in 12.75 months on average
Oecd and Luxembourg in 13.81 months
Oecd, far inside the pursued 24-month average
Oecd; Germany averaged 23.89 months
Oecd, just inside it
Oecd. Austria (32.84 months)
Oecd, Malta (45.50)
Oecd and the United States (37.33)
Oecd remained above the target
Oecd.
Germany's findings carry the sharpest practitioner warning. Peers reported that taxpayers may have to implicitly waive their MAP access to obtain an audit settlement or similar agreed outcome in Germany
Oecd, and that the competent authority must obtain the consent of the state tax administration
Oecd — which also performs the audit
Oecd — before agreeing substantive positions, leaving MAP staff without authority independent of the personnel who made the adjustments
Oecd. Germany's inventory still grew 7%
Oecd over 2018-23
Oecd, driven by a 31% rise in attribution/allocation cases
Oecd.
Austria cut its inventory by 21%
Oecd to 243 cases
Oecd but 56% of it is older than 24 months
Oecd, and peers flagged delays in position papers and resourcing
Oecd. Although Austria's policy is to grant MAP access where a domestic anti-abuse provision arguably conflicts with a treaty
Oecd, access was denied in one such case
Oecd; where a treaty sets no MAP filing period, Austrian domestic rules may also leave taxpayers less than three years from first notification
Oecd. Ireland's inventory more than tripled
Oecd to 177 cases
Oecd even as it closed files fast overall, with attribution/allocation cases averaging 32.90 months
Oecd. Luxembourg averaged 30.24 months on attribution/allocation cases
Oecd while that caseload rose 200%
Oecd.
Malta closed only 19% of the cases started in 2019-23
Oecd and its 23-case inventory
Oecd grew 283%
Oecd, with 12 of 21 new cases suspended pending court proceedings
Oecd and 61% of the stock older than 24 months
Oecd. The United States cut its total inventory by 34%
Oecd and its pre-2016 stock by 92%
Oecd, but its post-2015 caseload grew 60%
Oecd, close to a third of its 60 treaties
Oecd are not yet in line with the standard
Oecd, and some MAP agreements face timely-implementation issues
Oecd.
The reviews test compliance with the BEPS Action 14 minimum standard for making dispute resolution more effective, which requires treaty MAP provisions equivalent to Article 25 of the OECD Model Tax Convention; the five EU members reviewed also apply the EU Arbitration Convention and Directive 2017/1852, with remaining treaty gaps closed through the Multilateral Instrument, bilateral negotiations or both.
If you have cross-border disputes or treaty positions involving Austria, Germany, Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta or the United States, review open and prospective MAP cases against these findings — including audit-settlement practice in Germany — and allow longer resolution timelines for Austria, Malta and the United States.