NorwaySkatteetaten
Cross-border merger: claim takes market value at Norway entry
Conditional waivers with better-fortune clauses were deferred repayment, not a new right; the MEUR 150 claim entered Norway at around MEUR 110 market value, so the MEUR 80 collected was tax-free.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 17 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
Skatteklagenemnda's stor avdeling has upheld the taxpayer in SKNS1-2025-41
Skatteetaten, decided 12 June 2025 and published 17 November 2026. A Norwegian parent, A, had taken over the creditor position when it absorbed D in a cross-border merger under skatteloven § 11-11. D had lent MEUR 160 to its subsidiary E in 2007 and later signed four conditional debt waivers covering MEUR 150, each paired with an amendment summarising the remaining debt. E subsequently paid A around MNOK 800, equal to MEUR 80, over four years. The tax office treated the original loan as finally waived and the waivers as a new standalone right with an entry value of zero, so that the payments were taxable, primarily as dividend. The board majority disagreed on both points.
The waivers were not a final forgiveness but a deferral
Skatteetaten. Each waiver provided that debt waived would be repaid and automatically reintegrated if E returned to better fortune
Skatteetaten, capped by reference to net equity above 60 per cent of share capital and limited to fifteen years. That wording can hardly be read any other way than as a duty to settle the debt once E is able to, up to the originally agreed loan amount and nothing more. The amendments only summarised what remained of that same loan, and the arrangement was never formally converted into equity, so there was no basis for reclassifying the payments as dividend
Skatteetaten. That E carried the conditional duty off the balance sheet reflects probability of payment, not the absence of a legal duty.
With the payments classified as loan repayment, the question was whether the repayment produced a taxable gain for A. Repayment of a claim is a realisation under skatteloven § 9-2 first paragraph letter d, taxable under § 5-30 when connected to the taxpayer's business. The board found that connection present: financing forms part of A's overall business, and taking over E extended a value chain A controls. The § 9-3 shelter for claims outside a business therefore did not apply, and the gain turned entirely on the claim's entry value.
The starting point is historic cost, here a nominal MEUR 150, but special reasons called for market value at entry into the Norwegian tax jurisdiction instead
Skatteetaten. Under §§ 11-7 and 11-11, continuity is only relevant for tax positions that existed for Norwegian tax purposes before the merger, which this claim did not. Value changes before entry cannot be attributed to Norwegian activity: historic cost would both let Norway tax gains that accrued abroad and open the door to importing foreign losses, eroding the Norwegian tax base. The board estimated market value at the merger at around MEUR 110
Skatteetaten and found that estimate credible, so the MEUR 80 collected did not exceed the entry value
Skatteetaten and no gain arose
Skatteetaten. One member dissented on allocation only, holding that the MEUR 110 entry value spreads across the whole MEUR 150 claim so that only 72.72 per cent of it shelters the partial repayments.
The gain rules applied sit in skatteloven §§ 9-2, 9-3 and 5-30, with entry value following from §§ 11-7 and 11-11 as read in light of the preparatory works and the Utv. 2011 s. 285 line of practice on claims entering Norwegian taxation.
Test conditional intra-group waivers for a genuine repayment duty before conceding dividend treatment, and value claims taken in through a cross-border merger at entry-date market value with documented debtor capacity.