European UnionEUR-Lex
EU court: customs appeal does not block duty remission claim
Importers can pursue remission while their customs appeal is pending, but customs may still refuse to send the file to the Commission, the General Court held in an e-bike origin case.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 18 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
The General Court held on 18 November 2026 in case T-670/25 that appealing a customs-debt notification does not bar a remission claim for the same debtEuropa. The appeal right under Article 44 of the Union Customs Code and the repayment and remission procedure under Articles 116 and 121 are independent
Europa: a debtor who has appealed may still seek remission before the appeal ends
Europa, and that request is admissible
Europa.
Romanian importer Elvada Company SRL declared electric bicycles as Turkish origin on A.TR movement certificates and paid no duty. After a 2022 European Anti-Fraud Office inquiry into two Turkish exporters, Romanian customs reassessed the goods on 31 May 2023 as Chinese origin and charged duty plus a 62.1% anti-dumping duty and a 17.2% countervailing duty under Implementing Regulations (EU) 2019/73 and (EU) 2019/72. Elvada appealed; the court upheld the debt on 10 October 2024. Days later Elvada sought full remission, pleading error by the authorities and alternatively equity, asking for transmission to the Commission and suspension of payment. The customs offices refused to transmit and parked the requests until the final appeal judgment.
Article 121(3), the Court held, suspends only the three-year filing period during an Article 44 appeal, not examination of a parallel requestEuropa. The appeal sits among persons' rights and secures effective judicial protection under Article 47 of the Charter; repayment and remission sit in the recovery chapter as an exceptional mechanism for cases where collection after the event would offend legitimate expectations. A debtor may therefore deny the debt on appeal while seeking remission on the distinct Articles 119 and 120 grounds
Europa, which can lead to a Commission decision under Article 116(3). A national court that learns the Commission has been seised of the same debt must avoid contradicting the envisaged decision and may stay its proceedings.
Customs may however refuse to transmit the file where they consider the Articles 119 and 120 conditions unmetEuropa, even relying on a non-final judgment confirming the debt. Article 116(3) requires transmission only where customs consider remission warranted under Article 119 or 120 and a listed case applies: a Commission failure, a Commission error within Article 119, findings of a Union investigation such as OLAF work under Regulation (EC) No 515/97, or exposure of EUR 500,000 or more
Europa. A national grant would escape review, while a refusal can be challenged before national courts, which may refer questions to the Union courts. The third question, asked only if transmission could not be refused, needed no answer.
Importers should run both tracks together: file any claim under Article 119 (error by the competent authorities) or Article 120 (equity) within three years of the date of notification of the customs debtEuropa, a period suspended during an Article 44 appeal
Europa, and frame it for the Article 116(3) transmission test. From 21 September 2027 Article 222(3) of Regulation (EU) 2026/2108 replaces Article 121(3) and expressly addresses suspension of examination.
Legal basis is Regulation (EU) No 952/2013, Articles 44, 108, 116, 119, 120 and 121, applied alongside Implementing Regulations (EU) 2019/72 and (EU) 2019/73, Regulation (EC) No 515/97 and, for the future rule, Regulation (EU) 2026/2108, Articles 222(3) and 287(2).
If you have appealed a customs-debt notification, file any Article 119 or Article 120 remission claim within the appeal-suspended three-year period instead of waiting for the final judgment.