United KingdomGOV.UK
HMRC review may rest on earlier letter if three tests met
Officers offering a statutory review may now incorporate an earlier decision letter by reference where it states the substantive view, remains accurate and complete, and answers the customer's grounds.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 17 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
Where an HMRC decision maker offers a statutory review of a direct tax decision and refers back to an earlier letter for the view of the matter, that reference is now permitted only where the earlier letter meets three tests.GOV The letter must set out HMRC's substantive view, including the relevant facts and reasons for the decision.
GOV It must remain an accurate and complete statement of HMRC's current view.
GOV And it must address any relevant grounds, evidence or arguments the customer has raised in relation to the matter under appeal.
GOV Before issuing the view of the matter, the decision maker must consider any relevant grounds, evidence or arguments raised since the earlier letter was issued and address any points not already covered.
Where the substantive reasons sit separately from the decision or assessment notice, the view of the matter should refer to the letter containing those reasons. In a penalty case that means referring to the penalty explanation letter rather than only to the notice of penalty assessment. This creates no duty to comment on a new matter outside the scope of the decision under appeal. Where the customer appeals against a closure notice, the scope of the appeal stays limited to the specific conclusions made, or amendments given effect, by that notice, and the review process cannot alter that scope. Officers should not be drawn into substantive comment on grounds of appeal that were neither raised during the enquiry into the return nor addressed in the closure notice.
The surrounding offer mechanics are unchanged. The review offer letter must always go directly to the customer, even where HMRC routinely deals with an agentGOV, though a copy may go to the agent. The letter must set out HMRC's current view of the matter
GOV, and that letter may be issued only once: a fresh letter follows only where the original did not cover all the decisions under appeal or the review offer was invalid
GOV. If the view has not changed since the appeal was made, the letter confirms that the law requires HMRC to state its most recent view and that the view remains as set out in the decision letter of the given date. If the view has changed, the letter sets out which points are resolved, what is outstanding, and HMRC's view on the appropriate tax treatment of unresolved matters, including the amount of tax thought due where appropriate.
A customer who disagrees has 30 days from the date of the review offer letter to accept the offer of review or notify the appeal to the tribunal.GOV The letter must explain this choice, name who to write to when accepting (usually HMRC Legal Group), invite representations in support of the customer's position, and warn that doing neither means the appeal is treated as settled on the basis of HMRC's view of the matter
GOV. Once a review is offered the case moves to resolution: silence settles the appeal, accepting the review but not notifying the tribunal settles it on the review conclusions, and notifying the appeal sends the matter to the tribunal. An offer without a current view of the matter is not valid.
GOV
Legal basis: section 49C of the Taxes Management Act 1970, which requires the review offer to carry HMRC's view of the matterLegislation, allows 30 days from the offer document for acceptance
Legislation, and treats the appeal as settled on that view where the customer does not reply; section 49F gives review conclusions the same settled effect where the customer does not notify the appeal to the tribunal.
When a review offer incorporates an earlier letter by reference, test it against the three conditions and put any post-letter grounds, evidence or arguments on the record within the 30-day window.
Sources
- Review of direct and indirect taxes decisions: arranging for a review: HMRC offer of a review (direct taxes)
- Reviews and appeals for direct taxes: Appealing against a decision: Current view of the matter not sent or unsatisfactory
- Taxes Management Act 1970
- Reviews and appeals overview: Process for direct taxes