United KingdomCase Law
Privy Council denies dishonest director credit for parent top-ups
The Board allows the liquidator's appeal: EHL's £32.3m share subscriptions do not reduce the damages for breach of fiduciary duty, and the Icebreaker policies survive exclusion-clause and public-policy attacks.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 17 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A director in dishonest breach of fiduciary duty cannot reduce his damages by pointing to capital his company's parent later injected to keep the company afloat.
Nationalarchives In Enterprise Insurance Company Plc (in liquidation) v Flowers [2026] UKPC 40, given on 17 November 2026, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council allowed the liquidator's appeal
Nationalarchives and held that no deduction should be made from the damages or equitable compensation payable to Enterprise Insurance Company (EIC)
Nationalarchives for the £32.3 million its holding company EHL paid for additional EIC shares
Nationalarchives. The director's cross-appeal failed on both grounds.
Nationalarchives
EIC was a Gibraltar insurer. It entered provisional liquidation in July 2016 and was compulsorily wound up as insolvent, with the deficit estimated at around £200 million. Andrew Flowers, EIC's managing director from 2003 to 2014, was found to have acted in dishonest breach of fiduciary duty
Nationalarchives and in breach of his duty of reasonable care and skill by allowing EIC funds to be diverted to a sister company for non-existent services, and by underwriting insurance for investors in the Icebreaker tax avoidance scheme without establishing any reserves. The Court of Appeal had ordered credit for the £32.3 million EHL subscribed for new EIC shares
Nationalarchives, of which £8.3 million came from dividends received from the sister company and £24 million from bonds EHL issued on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange.
The Board, in a judgment given by Lord Reed, held that Flowers had not discharged the evidential burden of proving EIC received a benefit at all
Nationalarchives. The trial judge had found that the recirculation of money allowed EIC to stagger on unprofitably, to keep writing premium without adequate provision, and to channel further sums to Flowers and other ultimate beneficial owners: the fresh money was a disbenefit, and at minimum no benefit was established. On the hypothesis that a benefit had been received, it would not have been deductible in any event. The bond-funded payments were an independent response to the consequences of the wrongdoing; EHL subscribed intending to increase EIC's working capital so it could continue trading, not to discharge a dishonest director's liabilities; and treating a parent's support payments as reducing the liability for the very wrongdoing that created the need for support would be unjust and unreasonable.
On the Icebreaker cross-appeal, clause 11.4 of the policy, which excludes liability where the insurer reasonably believes the insured colluded with the partnership to engineer its failure, gave EIC no defence
Nationalarchives. An investor could not affect how the scheme operated, could not negotiate its structure or how funds were invested, and had no control over the intellectual property selected: merely investing on the terms offered is not collusion, and entering into the scheme is not an attempt to engineer its failure. There were no reasonable grounds for any such belief. Construing entry into the scheme as collusion would mean nobody investing in the scheme could ever benefit from a policy designed specifically to protect such investors, which would negate the policy's purpose entirely.
Nor were the Icebreaker policies void as contrary to public policy.
Nationalarchives Tax avoidance schemes are not unlawful, and neither are insurance contracts for such schemes. Parliament's interventions, including the general anti-abuse rule in Part 5 of the Finance Act 2013 and the sideways loss relief restriction in section 74ZA of the Income Tax Act 2007, operate only to deny the tax benefit, with no effect on the lawfulness, validity or enforceability of the arrangements. Patel v Mirza arose from established illegality, which was not the position here, and the single-judge permission decisions on the Financial Services Compensation Scheme point have no authority as precedents.
If you act on a breach-of-duty damages claim, plead and evidence benefit and deductibility as separate questions: fresh capital that deepens the loss is no credit, and tax-avoidance-linked policies are not void for public policy.