EstoniaRiigikohus
Missing minutes don't kill meeting challenges, top court rules
Riigikohus revived a challenge to an apartment association's articles amendment: an objection raised but left unminuted through the chair's error still preserves the right to sue; a mere no-vote does not.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 18 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
On 18 November 2026 the Supreme Court civil chamber (Vutt, Paal, Triipan) ruled in case 2-24-11813/34, TYCOON OÜ's challenge to the Tallinn Võistluse tn 6 apartment association's 30 June 2024 general meeting. The court annulled the circuit court's 15 May 2026 order refusing the member's claim against decision 1
Riigikohus — the new articles
Riigikohus — plus the costs allocation, remanded the case
Riigikohus and satisfied the complaint. The county court's invalidation of decision 2, the retroactive approval of a disputed cost-allocation formula, had become final because only the member appealed, so only the articles amendment is now before the courts.
The ruling's central holding concerns who may challenge a legal person's resolution. A member present may seek invalidation under TsÜS §38(4) second sentence, applied via KrtS §29(2), only with a minuted objection.
Riigikohus The objection serves legal certainty: it warns members present that the voter rejects the result and may challenge it, and flags possible unlawfulness before the vote. Merely voting against a motion is not an objection
Riigikohus, since a no-vote shows disagreement but not necessarily a view that the decision is unlawful; conversely, the objector need not expressly announce an intent to sue — it is enough that a reasonable member present understands the speaker considers the motion materially or procedurally contrary to law or the articles. Later challenge without a minuted objection would contradict that earlier conduct and breach good faith.
Minuting is required
Riigikohus, but a missing minute is not always fatal
Riigikohus. An objection raised at the meeting still counts as duly raised where it went unminuted through the chair's or secretary's error or bad faith
Riigikohus; the assessment turns on the substance of what was said, not its heading, isolated words or mistaken expressions
Riigikohus, and the minutes, while important, are not the only admissible proof
Riigikohus — otherwise an association could defeat every challenge by simply leaving objections out of the minutes. Running the meeting and arranging proper minuting of objections is the chair's duty under KrtS §20(1) via MTÜS §21(6); a member whose tendered objection document is refused cannot be blamed for the gap.
That is what happened here. The member had objected to the cost formula before the meeting in the Korto environment, tendered the objection document at the meeting where the chair treated it as an agenda-amendment and compromise proposal and refused it, and resubmitted the full document immediately after the meeting. Objections generally count only until the meeting closes, so neither the advance Korto statement nor the post-meeting resubmission sufficed alone — but the objection voiced at the meeting did
Riigikohus, and its message could surprise no one. The circuit court's contrary conclusion was a wrong legal assessment of established facts
Riigikohus, so its order had to go
Riigikohus.
On substance the court steered the remand: the articles amendment is not void
Riigikohus, and a KrtS §40(2) breach makes it voidable at most under the first sentence of TsÜS §38(1)
Riigikohus. The KrtS §40(1) default is pro-rata contributions by co-ownership share, tied to special-ownership size; the §40(2) articles-based exception is narrow, allowed only exceptionally where reasonable without excessively harming any owner. An exclusive-use part resembles special ownership, so charging measurable heating and electricity costs to exclusive users alone may be fair — a cost jump for a large exclusive holder does not alone make the formula unreasonable, while charging excluded owners may harm them. The remand court must still decide whether the garage's far lower actual consumption makes the split excessively harmful. Costs stay with the court deciding the case. Legal basis: TsÜS §38(1) and (4); KrtS §§20, 29 and 40; MTÜS §21(6); TsMS §§688, 691, 692 and 695.
State illegality objections on the record at the meeting and secure their minuting; chairs must minute objections and accept tendered documents.