European UnionEUR-Lex
AG backs DNB power to vet crypto firms' controls at registration
Advocate General proposes the Court allow DNB to demand governance proof at registration and refuse incomplete files in the Dutch 2020-2021 supervision-fee dispute.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Financial and insurance activities
On 19 November 2026Europa Advocate General Jean Richard de la Tour
Europa proposed that the Court of Justice uphold the Dutch registration model for crypto-asset service providers
Europa in Case C-415/25
Europa. A supervisor may, at registration, require material on how the firm is organised to operate with integrity and under control
Europa, and refuse registration where the file is incomplete or the supervisor remains unconvinced of its accuracy. He puts that answer to the Court for its preliminary ruling.
The reference from the College van Beroep voor het bedrijfslevenEuropa arises in a dispute between De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB) and eleven Dutch providers
Europa of exchange services between virtual currencies and legal currencies and of custodian wallet services. Since 21 May 2020 those providers fall within the Wet ter voorkoming van witwassen en financieren van terrorisme (Wwft)
Europa, with DNB as supervisor
Europa. Ten were registered in 2020 and one in 2021, each paying an uncontested EUR 5,000 registration-handling charge. DNB then charged ongoing supervision costs for 2020 and 2021, confirmed on objection in 2022. The rechtbank Rotterdam upheld the 2020 charges but annulled the 2021 charges in judgments of 4 October 2023; both sides appealed.
Under Articles 23b to 23d of the Wwft, these providers must register with DNBEuropa and supply information fixed by implementing rules
Europa, including the organisation of the business with a view to sound and controlled operations within the meaning of Article 23j. DNB asks in practice for the compliance and audit set-up, breach-reporting and outsourcing arrangements, training policy, integrity-risk analysis, conflicts-of-interest, customer due diligence, sanctions-screening and transaction-monitoring policies and procedures. Registration is withheld only where the data are incomplete or verification leaves DNB unconvinced of their accuracy.
Europa
The Rotterdam court treated that package as an authorisation regime going beyond the registration in Article 47 of Directive (EU) 2015/849Europa and therefore contrary to Union law
Europa. The referring court asks whether Article 47 precludes requiring business-organisation material aimed at showing the provider will be able to meet national anti-money-laundering requirements after registration, and refusing registration on that basis.
Europa
The Advocate General answers no on both points.Europa Registration, literally the entry of a person in a public register to allow later identification, does not exclude prior checks
Europa, unlike an authorisation understood as a state permission to pursue an activity. The legislative history does not show that retaining only registration for these providers was meant to empty it of substance, and the later Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 has since moved them to a fully harmonised authorisation regime. Structurally, Article 5 of Directive 2015/849 lays down minimum harmonisation and Article 48 requires effective supervision with power to demand any information relevant to compliance, so Member States may ask for additional material at registration where it serves the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing within the limits of Union law
Europa. Integrity and controlled management match that preventive purpose for a fast, partly anonymous, high-risk activity: without a prior check, illicit flows could pass through a newly registered provider before any subsequent control bites.
The refusal ground is bounded: withholding follows only from incomplete or unconvincing materialEuropa, reviewable by a court, and may lead DNB to test the coherence of planned risk policies and the fitness of managers and shareholders rather than to decide arbitrarily. The Advocate General adds that the referring court must verify that the conditions under which DNB implements the requirement respect proportionality, legality, legal certainty and non-discrimination.
Legal basis: Article 47 of Directive (UE) 2015/849, read with Articles 5 and 48 of that directive, and Articles 23b to 23d and 23j of the Wwft.
Crypto-asset exchanges and custodians seeking registration with DNB should assemble the full sound-and-controlled-operations file, from integrity-risk analysis to customer due diligence, sanctions screening and transaction monitoring, as part of the application.