European UnionEUR-Lex
Both payee and payer providers supply direct debit, Court rules
The Court holds both sides' providers supply the direct debit service, even where the payee-side firm only forwards orders into limited-access accounts; acquiring and initiation-service questions fell away.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Financial Sector & MarketsLegal & Corporate
Industry: Financial service activities, except insurance and pension funding
On 19 November 2026 the Court of Justice (First Chamber) ruled that both the payee's payment service provider and the payer's payment service provider supply the direct debit service when a direct debit is executedEuropa
Europa, in Case C-274/25. A payee-side provider that only transmits direct debit orders and collects the funds into accounts of limited functionality still provides a direct debit service.
Europa Fallback questions about classification as acquiring or as a payment initiation service therefore needed no answer.
Europa
The reference from the Lietuvos vyriausiasis administracinis teismas arises from a licence withdrawal. Alternative Payments UAB, licensed by Lietuvos bankas on 16 September 2014 for issuing or acquiring means of payment and for money remittance, joined the SEPA CENTROlink system in 2017. On 26 August 2022 the Bank of Lithuania withdrew the licence after finding, among other infringements, unlicensed direct debit provision. The Vilniaus apygardos administracinis teismas dismissed the firm's challenge on 14 September 2023, and the firm appealed.
Alternative Payments' customers are merchants collecting payment from their buyers. The buyer consents to the merchant debiting the buyer's account, the merchant initiates the debit, and Alternative Payments sends the orders into the SEPA direct debit scheme through CENTROlink. The buyer's account is debited by the buyer's own provider. The funds land on customer accounts inside Alternative Payments' system to which customers have no access and from which they cannot pay; the firm then forwards the money to accounts the customers hold with other providers.
On the first question the Court reads the definitions together: Regulation (EU) No 260/2012, Article 2(2) and Directive (EU) 2015/2366, Article 4(23) define a direct debit as debiting the payer's account on the payee's initiative with the payer's consentEuropa
Europa, which the directive says may be given to the payee, the payee's provider or the payer's provider
Europa. Executing one involves four parties, with the payee's provider transmitting the order and collecting the debited funds and the payer's provider debiting the account, with no hierarchy between those steps. The context confirms it: Directive 2015/2366, Articles 81(3) and 83(3) impose duties specifically on the payee's provider, to see the payee receives the full amount and to forward the order in time for settlement on the due date. The mandate definition in Regulation No 260/2012, Article 2(21) likewise describes a transaction carried out by both sides. Construing both providers as suppliers avoids fragmenting the service and serves the aims of closing gaps and applying the framework consistently.
On the second question, that only the payer's provider performs the debitEuropa is irrelevant
Europa within a necessarily joint transaction
Europa, and collection is expressly part of a direct debit under Article 2(20) of Regulation No 260/2012
Europa. The limited-functionality accounts are equally irrelevant
Europa: the definitions impose no account characteristics beyond holding a payment account used for executing transactions
Europa, and the collection accounts here were identified by IBAN and received payments processed through a central-bank-managed system.
Routing direct debit orders therefore places a payee-side provider under points 3(a) and 4(a) of Annex I to Directive 2015/2366Europa — the classification at issue where a licence covering only issuing or acquiring and money remittance was withdrawn
Europa — and limited-access collection accounts do not change the analysis
Europa. How the withdrawal fares on the facts is now for the Lithuanian court
Europa, which also decides costs.
Legal basis: Article 2(2) of Regulation (EU) No 260/2012 and Article 4(23) of Directive (EU) 2015/2366, with points 3(a) and 4(a) of Annex I to that directive.
Payee-side providers that transmit direct debit orders should check that their licence covers execution of direct debits, since collection accounts with limited functionality do not take the activity outside the direct debit classification.