European UnionEUR-Lex
AG: Micula award payment is no State aid advantage
The Advocate General proposes setting aside the 2024 judgment and annulling the aid finding for lack of advantage: the right came from the award, not its payment; damages are not unpaid incentives.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
On 19 November 2026 Advocate General Rantos proposed that the Court of Justice set aside the General Court's 2024 Micula judgmentEuropa and annul the core of the Commission's State aid decision on the Romanian arbitral award
Europa, in Joined Cases C-890/24 P and C-891/24 P. The payment of damages under the award was not, in his view, an economic advantage within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU
Europa. He puts that answer to the Court on the appeals.
The dispute goes back to a 1998 Romanian emergency ordinance granting tax incentives, including customs, VAT and profit-tax relief, to investors in disfavoured regions. Companies of the group run by Swedish nationals Ioan and Viorel Micula invested under the scheme from the 2000s. Romania repealed the incentives on 26 August 2004 with effect from 22 February 2005, before its accession to the Union on 1 January 2007. Five claimants sought arbitration in 2005 under the 2002 Sweden-Romania bilateral investment treaty, and on 11 December 2013 the tribunal ordered Romania to pay RON 791,882,452, about EUR 178 million, for failing to ensure fair and equitable treatment. By Decision (EU) 2015/1470 of 30 March 2015 the Commission treated payment of that compensation as incompatible State aidEuropa and ordered recovery from a single economic unit of the brothers and eight companies, jointly liable.
The General Court first annulled the decision in 2019 for lack of Commission competence and misclassification of the award. In 2022 the Court of Justice set that judgment aside, held the Commission competent on the ground that the right to compensation had been conferred solely by the awardEuropa, which also fixed its amount, and sent the case back. On 2 October 2024 the General Court dismissed the actions, rejecting seven pleas. The present appeals were joined in February 2025.
The Advocate General's central point turns on what the aid measure is. The Commission defined it as the payment implementing the awardEuropa, but the Court of Justice has already held that the right was conferred solely by the award itself. Under settled case-law, aid is granted when the right to receive it is conferred under the applicable legislation, so the right cannot result solely from Romania implementing the award, whether voluntarily or by enforcement
Europa. That mismatch alone, he considers, justifies setting the 2024 judgment aside
Europa.
In the alternative, the damages fail the advantage test under the Asteris and DOBELES HES case-lawEuropa. The tribunal penalised Romania's conduct towards the investors at the repeal, a breach of fair and equitable treatment, and heads such as lost profits cannot simply be equated with unpaid incentives
Europa. The General Court never examined how far the damages related to the period after accession, and the Romanian Competition Council's year-2000 finding on the incentives is irrelevant because Union law applied only from accession. The reasoning limiting State aid findings in court judgments to actions seeking compensation for unpaid aid transposes to arbitral tribunals, which stand equally apart from public authorities.
The rest of the Commission's construction survives his reviewEuropa: he would reject the cross-appeal on admissibility, the Article 351 TFEU and imputability arguments, and the challenges on compatibility, the single economic entity and recovery
Europa. If the Court follows the advantage analysis, it can itself uphold the no-advantage plea and annul Article 1 of the 2015 decision
Europa.
Groups facing recovery of intra-Union treaty-award sums should track the appeals and keep Asteris-based and temporal arguments live: the 2015 decision orders Romania to recover sums already paid and to make no further paymentsEuropa.
Legal basis: Article 107(1) TFEU and the first paragraph of Article 351 TFEU, with Article 1 of Commission Decision (EU) 2015/1470.
Groups facing recovery of intra-Union treaty-award sums should track Joined Cases C-890/24 P and C-891/24 P and keep Asteris-based and temporal arguments live.
Sources
- OPINION OF ADVOCATE GENERAL RANTOS delivered on 19 November 2026 — Joined Cases C-890/24 P
- COMMISSION DECISION (EU) 2015/1470 of 30 March 2015 on State aid SA.38517 (2014/C) (ex 2014/NN) implemented by Romania — Arbitral award Micula v Romania of 11 December 2013 (notified under document C(2015) 2112) (Only the Romanian text is authentic) (Text with EEA relevance)