United KingdomCase Law
Will trustees reach whole fund for life-interest years, not later splits
A will's single life-interest trust exposes the whole fund to liabilities from those years, but after the life tenant's death each child's share is a separate trust shielded from the rest.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 20 November 2026
Trustees of a will that gives a life interest in the whole residue
Nationalarchives and then splits specific properties between children
Nationalarchives can satisfy liabilities from the life-interest years out of any of the estate's assets, including property now held outright for one child.
Nationalarchives Liabilities run up solely in administering one child's separate share after the life tenant's death cannot be laid against another child's share.
Nationalarchives That is how Deputy Master Holden construed the will of Benjamin Dollimore
Nationalarchives, who died in 1983
Nationalarchives leaving residue on trust for his widow for life
Nationalarchives, three property groups for his children on her death
Nationalarchives, and a power to advance capital to the widow if income fell short
Nationalarchives.
The dispute is driven by a contaminated lime quarry. The trustees let it in 2005; after the tenant company was sold in December 2014, at least 200,000 cubic metres of waste were dumped and buried there between about February 2015 and October 2017. The two men behind the dumping were prosecuted and sentenced on 20 October 2023. The trustees face potential remediation costs estimated at up to £50 million and a possible Landfill Tax bill near £45 million plus penalties of up to 100 per cent. Those figures are estimates only: the judgment determines neither the existence nor the amount of any liability, nor whether any of it was properly incurred.
The trustees argued the will created a single settlement, so their indemnity reaches the whole fund. Elizabeth Christie, entitled under the will to a third group of properties including 4 St Albans Road, Codicote, argued each property group was a separate trust from the start, so Quarry liabilities fall only on the Quarry's share held for Julie Eastwell. HMRC, joined over Inheritance Tax on the widow's death, was removed as a party on 7 July 2026 with its costs paid by the trustees, first securing a recital that its statutory charge under section 237 of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984 extends to the whole of the property in which Doris held a life interest. The trustees may pay Inheritance Tax before other liabilities are ascertained.
The court held that during the widow's lifetime the estate was one common fund
Nationalarchives: a single gift of residue
Nationalarchives, one life tenant
Nationalarchives, one body of trustees
Nationalarchives, and an advancement power ranging over the whole capital
Nationalarchives meant the children's vested remainder interests were defeasible
Nationalarchives and their shares unknowable until her death
Nationalarchives. The trustees' indemnity for liabilities attributable to administering that common fund therefore extends to all of its assets
Nationalarchives and survived the widow's death
Nationalarchives on 15 October 2015
Nationalarchives. But from that date each property group has been held on a separate bare trust
Nationalarchives, so later liabilities incurred exclusively in administering the Quarry trust are not expenses incurred on behalf of Ms Christie's trust
Nationalarchives and cannot be reimbursed from it under section 31(1) of the Trustee Act 2000
Nationalarchives.
For trustees and creditors, timing is now decisive. A contingent liability from the common-fund years, or a later expense resolving it, may still belong to that fund even if demanded after the life tenant's death
Nationalarchives; but owning and leasing the Quarry in her lifetime does not make every later Quarry expense a common-fund liability
Nationalarchives. Placing each liability on either side of that line, and apportioning the burden between beneficiaries, are reserved for further directions. Legal basis: section 31(1) and section 39(1) of the Trustee Act 2000 and section 237 of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984
Nationalarchives, construed in Lendrum v Eastwell [2026] EWHC 3017 (BP)
Nationalarchives applying Roome v Edwards, Hardoon v Belilios and Equity Trust v Halabi
Nationalarchives.
If you advise trustees of a will trust holding separately gifted properties, attribute each liability to the period in which it arose and seek court directions before meeting one beneficiary's share of liabilities from another beneficiary's property.