European UnionEUR-Lex
AG: apple distributor paying on resale average is a buyer
Substance over labels decides buyer status, the Advocate General proposes, and the sixty-day period runs from delivery where only the operator can compute the amount; the Court has yet to rule.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Wholesale of food, beverages and tobacco
On 19 November 2026Europa Advocate General Andrea Biondi
Europa proposed criteria for deciding when a food distributor is a buyer subject to the late-payment ban in the agri-food chain
Europa, in Case C-592/25. Substance prevails over the contract label: an operator that takes the products and decides on resale instead of the producer, owing the producer the price, is a buyer even if the paperwork says commission
Europa. Where the amount due depends on operations only the operator performs, the sixty-day period runs from delivery, not from the final settlement
Europa. He puts both answers to the Court for its preliminary ruling.
The reference from the Oberlandesgericht Wien, sitting as cartel court, arises from fine proceedings by the Bundeswettbewerbsbehörde against Aroma Obst GmbH, an Austrian apple distributor between producers and food retailers. Aroma Obst collects apples at harvest, stores them by variety and quality, and sells on variety and quality alone while the producers play no part in retailer negotiations. It pays advances; the balance follows only once all apples of a variety are sold, at the season's average resale price minus costs of about 25 to 27 cents per kilogram. A harvest form headed sale contract still provides for settlement on commission. For 2022 deliveries the authority seeks fines for paying two small producers in full more than sixty days after the delivery period expired or after deliveryEuropa, under Austrian rules allowing fines up to EUR 500,000.
On the buyer question, the Advocate General proposes an autonomous Union testEuropa. A buyer is the operator to whom products are delivered and who decides on their sale instead of the supplier, in particular to whom, when and at what price, and who owes the supplier the price
Europa. Not a buyer is the operator that sells for the supplier's account where the supplier keeps effective power, even if unexercised, to instruct those decisions, and the operator accounts for individual sales and hands over their proceeds
Europa. Contract name, retention of title, storage and sale services, return of unsold goods, shared interest in a high resale price and price risk left with the supplier do not as such exclude buyer status
Europa. Borderline cases call for an overall assessment weighing powers over the products and over customers, risk allocation, the form of remuneration, and whether the operator owes the price or must account for individual sales and hand over their proceeds.
Pooling proceeds at an average price points towards purchase rather than commission accounting for individual salesEuropa; price risk on producers and cost-based remuneration point the other way but are not decisive
Europa. The referring court must clarify the fate of unsold apples and sorting deductions.
On the payment clock, the buyer establishes the amount payable whenever the supplier cannot work it out independently because it turns on operations only the buyer performs or data only the buyer holds, such as selection, the price the buyer alone agrees with its customers, or deduction of buyer-set costsEuropa. The period then runs from expiry of the agreed delivery period for regular deliveries, or from the delivery date otherwise
Europa, and cannot be postponed to resale or the final settlement
Europa; advances do not make a late balance timely. Market-tracking price formulas and Article 172bis value-sharing clauses remain available
Europa. Whether deliveries are regular is for the national court, as is compliance delivery by delivery.
Legal basis: Articles 2(2) and 3(1)(a) of Directive (UE) 2019/633Europa, with Article 172bis of Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013 for value-sharing clauses.
Distributors that settle producers on post-sale average prices should check whether they act as buyers and organise payment within sixty days of delivery or delivery-period expiry rather than waiting for the final settlement.