United KingdomGOV.UK
Discovery letters must justify each issue assessed, HMRC tells officers
Explanation letters must state a discovery per issue and defend any assessing or time-limit condition per issue; flagging material uncertainties is best practice, and no assessment may be called protective.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 16 November 2026
Officers who issue a discovery assessment are now told to state in the explanation letter that they have made a discovery for each issue being assessed.GOV The letter must explain what discovery or discoveries the officer thinks have been made
GOV and why the information held at least points in the direction of a loss of tax.
GOV A single generic statement that tax has been lost no longer meets the internal standard
GOV; every issue assessed needs its own discovery footing set out in writing.
GOV
The same per-issue discipline applies to the conditions that allow the assessment at all. Where the assessment relies on an assessing condition, or on an extended time-limit condition, the letter must explain why the officer considers the condition available for each issue the assessment covers.GOV The assessing conditions are the familiar section 29 gateways: the loss of tax was brought about carelessly or deliberately, or the officer could not reasonably have been expected to be aware of the shortfall from the information made available when the enquiry window closed. The extended time-limit rules for assessments made after 31 March 2010 sit at CH53100.
Officers are also told, as best practice, to outline any important areas of factual or legal uncertainty they consider exist, and they must stop describing assessments as protectiveGOV. The legislation permits no protective assessment made merely to extend time to investigate or in case a loss of tax is discovered later
GOV; an assessment issued with time limits approaching is legitimate only where a loss of tax has already been discovered or the presumption of continuity can be relied on.
GOV Calling an assessment protective gives the impression it fails the basic discovery conditions and invites challenges through the appeals process that need never have arisen.
What the letter keeps is the taxpayer's route map: the right to appeal against the assessment, to seek a review of HMRC's decision and to apply for postponement of the tax charged. Where penalties are in contemplation, the officer still encloses factsheet CC/FS9 unless already sent and explains what it covers. Gone are two former requirements: the letter no longer needs to cite the legislation under which the assessment is issued, and the reminder that interest runs when tax is paid late has been dropped. The letter stays separate in principle from the assessment and its formal notification, though it can itself meet the requirements for valid notification.
The framework behind the rewrite is section 29 of the Taxes Management Act 1970, under which HMRC may assess to make good a loss of tax and bears the burden on appeal of showing the discovery on which the assessment was based, with adequate record keeping as the best defence of that burden.
On receiving a discovery assessment, test the explanation letter issue by issue: each assessed issue needs its own stated discovery and condition reasoning, and a letter calling the assessment protective is itself a ground of challenge.
Sources
- Discovery: issuing discovery assessments: notification to taxpayer
- Enquiries into Tax Returns: discovery assessments
- Discovery: issuing discovery assessments: qualifying conditions and evidence needed to issue a discovery assessment
- Discovery: legislation and time limits: legislation - individuals - Section 29, TMA 1970