United KingdomCase Law
Contract 'insolvency' trigger includes balance-sheet test, appeal court holds
Court of Appeal holds a joint-venture loan became repayable when the company was balance-sheet insolvent, so a 2022 guarantee claim was time-barred and the guarantee was discharged by variation.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 20 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
The Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Lewison, Lord Justice Zacaroli and Lady Justice Lieven) dismissed Mr Peter Dunn's appeal against dismissal of his guarantee claim against Mr Kostas Kazolides
Nationalarchives
Nationalarchives in Dunn v Kazolides [2026] EWCA Civ 1484, judgment given on 20 November 2026. The appeal was from the order of Sharif Shivji KC sitting as a deputy High Court judge, [2025] EWHC 2212 (Ch), on a guarantee in a joint venture agreement dated 29 August 2006 (the JVA).
The JVA concerned development of a Cyprus property into seven villas through Astriver Co Limited (the Company), owned by Mr Kazolides and Mr Christopher Stylianou. Funding came from Mr Dunn by way of loan (the PD Loan), increased by a supplemental agreement dated 12 April 2007 to CYP 800,000 plus further sums as reasonably required, at 8% compounded quarterly and secured by a first fixed charge over the property. By clause 18 the Company's obligations, including under the PD Loan, were guaranteed. The villas were completed in October 2010; the first was sold in 2018 and the remaining six in 2019 to a company connected with Mr Dunn. Mr Dunn issued his guarantee claim on 11 March 2022
Nationalarchives.
Clause 5(c) made the PD Loan automatically repayable on sale of the Company, a winding-up resolution, insolvency of the Company, or a creditor arrangement
Nationalarchives. It was common ground that the guarantee cause of action arose when the Company became liable to repay the PD Loan. The question was whether "the insolvency of the Company" meant inability to pay debts including the balance-sheet test, or only a specific event such as a formal proceeding or the cash-flow circumstances in section 123(1) of the Insolvency Act 1986.
The court held it means inability to pay debts in the full statutory sense, including the balance-sheet test in section 123(2)
Nationalarchives — proved where asset values fall below liabilities including contingent and prospective liabilities. Nothing in clause 5(c) distinguished the cash-flow test in section 123(1)(e) from the balance-sheet test, and the other three triggers formed no genus narrowing insolvency to a single event. Following BNY Corporate Trustee v Eurosail-UK [2013] UKSC 28, the court rejected arguments that the balance-sheet test was too uncertain or too easily satisfied in a development vehicle, or that Mr Dunn lacked information: the JVA gave him accounts and reports and entitled him to appoint a director, which he did from 2009. The court also rejected exclusion of the PD Loan from the assessment merely because Mr Dunn was content to wait for sales; prospective debts count even when not currently due.
On the facts the Company was balance-sheet insolvent from at least 30 September 2009
Nationalarchives, with a shortfall of 799,409 euros by early March 2010
Nationalarchives. The claim was therefore barred even on a 12-year period
Nationalarchives, so the court did not decide whether the period was 12 years as a deed or six years.
Separately, the court agreed the guarantee had in any event been discharged
Nationalarchives. In late 2009 Mr Dunn and the Company replaced the clause 14(1) duty to sell as soon as practicable with sale at a time and price of Mr Dunn's choosing, extending repayment time. Under Holme v Brunskill (1878) 3 QBD 495, a variation without the surety's consent discharges the guarantor unless evidently insubstantial or necessarily beneficial, and a binding extension of time does likewise. The sale-timing change, benefiting Mr Dunn, supplied consideration answering the mere-forbearance objection.
Legal basis: Insolvency Act 1986, sections 122(1)(f), 123(1)(e) and 123(2); guarantee discharge under Holme v Brunskill.
If your loan or guarantee uses a bare insolvency trigger, amend it to name the exact events you mean, and get each guarantor’s written consent before varying sale, repayment or timing terms.