United KingdomCase Law
Unproved bankruptcy dividend cannot block a statutory demand
Rushton J reinstates a trustee's demand: an unfiled £1.2m estate claim lacks mutuality with costs owed to the trustee, and the residual discretion is no general fairness power.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 20 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A debtor cannot set aside a statutory demand by pointing to a large but unproved claim he says he has in someone else's bankruptcy
Nationalarchives, and the court's residual discretion to set demands aside is not a general fairness power
Nationalarchives. Mrs Justice Rushton so held in allowing a trustee in bankruptcy's appeal
Nationalarchives, reinstating a £46,791 statutory demand
Nationalarchives and authorising presentation of a bankruptcy petition after 21 days
Nationalarchives.
The demand was served in August 2024 by Adrian Hyde, trustee in bankruptcy of Lord Magan, on Lord Magan's son Edward Magan, for indemnity costs ordered against the son that April after the trustee successfully applied for delivery up of boxes of documents the father had transferred to him. The son, who did not dispute the debt, applied to set it aside, relying on a potential claim of £1,228,306.83 he said he had as a creditor in his father's bankruptcy, and separately on a claim in the liquidation of Wilton (IOM) Limited, where Hyde was a joint liquidator. The district judge set the demand aside as premature, reasoning that money might become available from the estate. The trustee appealed with permission granted in October 2025.
On mutuality, the court agreed with the analysis in King v Bar Mutual and the Court of Appeal in Hurst v Bennett
Nationalarchives: a counterclaim, set-off or cross demand under rule 10.5(5)(a) of the Insolvency Rules 2016 must be in the same legal character as the demand debt
Nationalarchives. Costs owed to Hyde as trustee could not be answered by a claim the son said he had against his father's estate
Nationalarchives, and the son had already conceded the liquidation claim, being against a different party, lacked mutuality. Without mutuality there is no need to ask about any further connection between the claims
Nationalarchives.
On the residual discretion in rule 10.5(5)(d), the court held it does not confer a general discretion
Nationalarchives and cannot be used to admit cross claims wider than those allowed under sub-rule (a)
Nationalarchives. It covers cases such as a defective demand or evidence the debt will in substance be immediately paid, and may extend to abuse of process of the kind seen in Sky Wheels, where a demand was served to obstruct unfair prejudice proceedings. But abuse arguments had already been rejected below and were not pursued on appeal, the demand was not defective, and the son admitted he could not pay immediately, so no other ground was open.
On the alternative two-stage test for a cross demand, the alleged £1.2 million claim failed at the first stage
Nationalarchives: a remote chance of a dividend is not the real prospect of success required on summary-judgment principles
Nationalarchives, and with no proof of debt filed and no particulars given there was virtually no evidence to assess. The claim would have passed the quantum stage, since a dividend of 4p in the pound would have extinguished the debt, but that could not cure the absence of merits. The court ordered the son to pay the trustee's costs of the appeal and below, summarily assessed at £35,000 on the standard basis against £57,756.81 claimed, after reducing senior solicitor rates exceeding the guideline rates and applying a proportionality cut. Legal basis: rule 10.5 of the Insolvency (England and Wales) Rules 2016, applied in Hyde v Magan [2026] EWHC 2955 (BP) following Hurst v Bennett and King v Bar Mutual.
If you resist a statutory demand, plead any cross demand in the same legal character as the debt, file a proof of debt with particulars, and do not rely on the court's residual discretion as a general fairness jurisdiction.