United KingdomCase Law
Widow of sole shareholder validly appoints herself director without court order
Leech J extends the Duomatic principle to personal representatives, rejects a backdated lease and a sham letting, and holds a landlord who cancelled the rent standing order himself cannot forfeit without notice.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 20 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
The personal representative of a deceased sole shareholder can invoke the Duomatic principle to appoint a director
Nationalarchives without first being entered on the register of members
Nationalarchives and without applying to court under section 125 of the Companies Act 2006
Nationalarchives. So held Mr Justice Leech
Nationalarchives, upholding Shaheen Shan's self-appointment as director of Shans Supermarkets Ltd
Nationalarchives on 3 April 2023
Nationalarchives as administrator of her late husband's estate
Nationalarchives. The court answered a question left open by the Court of Appeal in Re BW Estates: a personal representative holds the estate's shares with full ownership pending administration
Nationalarchives, and, the court reasoned, Table A regulation 29 provides that if a member dies, the personal representative shall be the only person recognised as having any title to that member's interest. No regulation 30 election was needed, short notice did not matter in a single-member company, and the regulation 31 voting bar protects other members where none exist. Aftab Ali, who controlled the register while holding himself out as director, could not complain the company had no means of registering her
Nationalarchives.
Ali held all 500 issued shares
Nationalarchives and was sole director of the company
Nationalarchives, which has traded as a supermarket from Keighley freeholds owned by his brother Aftab since 2007. An AP01 filed on 26 January 2022, the day Ali died
Nationalarchives, stated Aftab had been appointed a director the previous day, and a second AP01 filed on 27 January did the same for another brother, Sajad. A separate declaration confirmed Ali's sole ownership until death
Nationalarchives. Shaheen obtained administration on 22 March 2023
Nationalarchives and probate on 22 January 2026
Nationalarchives.
A written lease of the supermarket whose term was expressed to begin on 3 January 2019
Nationalarchives was held not to bind the company
Nationalarchives. The court found it was executed on or after 5 April 2023
Nationalarchives and backdated
Nationalarchives: no original or drafts existed, no messages discussed it, its dates were inconsistent, and it omitted the customer car park held under a separate title. Instead the parties had an implied monthly periodic tenancy of the whole property
Nationalarchives at £3,500 a month
Nationalarchives, protected by Part II of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954
Nationalarchives. The court refused to imply a condition making punctual payment a condition of that tenancy
Nationalarchives, so late payment alone gave no right to forfeit
Nationalarchives.
By 6 April 2023 arrears stood at £52,500
Nationalarchives. But Aftab, acting as the tenant's de facto director, had himself cancelled the standing order paying rent
Nationalarchives, then took no step for over a year to demand payment. The court treated that as forbearance
Nationalarchives barring forfeiture without prior reasonable notice to pay
Nationalarchives, which he never gave
Nationalarchives. His re-entry of the premises on 6 April 2023
Nationalarchives was therefore unlawful
Nationalarchives, and a second lease whose term was expressed to begin on 7 April 2023
Nationalarchives, granting the supermarket to the second defendant
Nationalarchives at £126,000 a year
Nationalarchives, was a sham
Nationalarchives, executed after an injunction to simulate a new letting while the company's staff kept trading.
Aftab was also found to have removed the company's share register and books, safes holding cash, gold and jewellery, and computers and CCTV recorders, and to retain them; the company is entitled to delivery up under section 3 of the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977
Nationalarchives, the precise order reserved. Had any forfeitable tenancy existed, the court would have granted relief on payment of the arrears. Legal basis: sections 112, 113 and 125 of the Companies Act 2006 with Table A regulations 29 to 31, Part II of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954, and section 3 of the Torts (Interference with Goods) Act 1977, applied in Shans Supermarkets Ltd v Ali [2026] EWHC 3014 (BP).
If you act for a deceased sole shareholder's family, secure the grant and assert the personal representative's authority promptly, and never forfeit for arrears built up during your own forbearance without first giving reasonable notice to pay.