GermanyBundesfinanzhof
Ex-director liable if later taxes foreseeable at departure
The Federal Fiscal Court keeps a director swap in a shell burial valid but sends the fund-preservation breach back for full fact-finding.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A managing director who resigns in the course of a covert liquidation can still be liable for later taxes if their accrual was foreseeable and no provision was madeBundesfinanzhof. The Federal Fiscal Court held in VII R 14/25 of 8 September 2026 that the mere resolution replacing the director in a Firmenbestattung is voidable rather than void
Bundesfinanzhof, but that a dismissed director's breach of the duty to preserve funds can ground liability under section 69 of the Abgabenordnung even where the taxes arose only after the departure
Bundesfinanzhof. It set aside the Schleswig-Holstein Fiscal Court judgment
Bundesfinanzhof and remanded the case
Bundesfinanzhof.
The claimant, sole shareholder and director of a construction company, dismissed himself in May 2018, appointed a Bulgaria-resident successor twice replaced afterwards, sold his shares in January 2019, and saw the company file no 2018 or 2019 returns, face estimated assessments and be deleted for lack of assets in October 2021. The office assessed him in July 2023 for arrears due in June 2021. The Fiscal Court had annulled the assessment, treating the dismissal as ending section 34 status, the resolution as valid, and no crisis, siphoning, unfit successor or fund-preservation breach as shown.
The Federal Fiscal Court agreed the dismissal was effectiveBundesfinanzhof. A resolution merely changing the director is voidable, not void
Bundesfinanzhof: by analogy to section 241 point 4 of the Aktiengesetz, only a resolution offensive in itself is void
Bundesfinanzhof, while bad motive or adoption defects make it challengeable. With no further restructuring or directly creditor-harming resolution at the May 2018 date, the claimant ceased to be the section 34 representative then
Bundesfinanzhof and cannot answer as incumbent for later breaches
Bundesfinanzhof.
Liability for conduct up to departure remains open: a representative must keep funds available for foreseeable tax accruals, regardless of maturityBundesfinanzhof. A former director can be liable where recognisably accruing claims are left unprovided for
Bundesfinanzhof, and provision may already be required before the claim arises once accrual is foreseeable
Bundesfinanzhof. In a Firmenbestattung the question is whether, at handover, concrete circumstances made it foreseeable that the company would be steered planfully to deletion from the register without liquidation or insolvency and that its tax duties would foreseeably go unmet
Bundesfinanzhof. Expectable non-filing with consequent estimates and non-payment of the estimated taxes suffices for that foreseeability
Bundesfinanzhof.
The no-breach finding failed for incomplete and contradictory factsBundesfinanzhof. The 2017 balance sheet showed work in progress with netted advances under section 268(5) sentence 2 of the Handelsgesetzbuch, but not how that asset and the advances developed to May 2018 or where proceeds went. No-crisis rested only on the 2017 balance and a 2018 short report, with nothing on May 2018, and crisis may have been caused later by asset transfers. Successor fitness was assumed despite a non-German-speaking Bulgaria resident supposedly running a domestic building firm from the former director's flat, successive straw men, mass domicile addresses, public service and an undocumented share price. A thirteen-month address gap and multiple successors may indicate concealment, not rebuttal.
On remand the court must test foreseeability at handoverBundesfinanzhof and press the claimant, majority shareholder until January 2019, to cooperate under section 76 of the Finanzgerichtsordnung, with a reduced greatest-possible-probability standard if he refuses; otherwise the office bears the burden on liability facts.
The legal basis is sections 34(1), 69 sentence 1, 191(1) sentence 1 alternative 1 and 37 of the Abgabenordnung with sections 35(1) sentence 1 of the GmbH-Gesetz, section 241 point 4 of the Aktiengesetz, section 138 and section 826 of the Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, sections 76, 96, 118 and 126(3) sentence 1 point 2 of the Finanzgerichtsordnung and section 268(5) sentence 2 of the Handelsgesetzbuch.
Before resigning from a distressed company, document provision for foreseeable tax accruals and vet the successor's fitness and address trail.