GermanyBundesfinanzhof
Rooftop PV rights are no split, but intra-group rent needs fix
BFH preserves the extended property reduction for 2008 because roof-use rights were no essential business asset, but sends 2009-2010 back to correct paid intra-group use inside the fiscal unity.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Renting and operating of own or leased real estate
Roof-use rights for photovoltaic plants can create a business split, but did not do so where the operator is mainly a service business and solar is a marginal sidelineBundesfinanzhof. Paid intra-group use inside a fiscal unity still needs correction so the parent keeps no unjustified extended reduction
Bundesfinanzhof.
The Bundesfinanzhof so heldBundesfinanzhof on 13 August 2026
Bundesfinanzhof, III R 12/25
Bundesfinanzhof. For 2008 the extended reduction under § 9 Nr. 1 Satz 2 GewStG stands
Bundesfinanzhof because there was no Betriebsaufspaltung
Bundesfinanzhof. For 2009 and 2010 the court also found no split
Bundesfinanzhof, but remanded
Bundesfinanzhof: the Finanzgericht Düsseldorf judgment of 19 February 2025 had not examined whether paid roof use inside the Organkreis was neutralised between add-backs and the extended reduction
Bundesfinanzhof.
The plaintiff, a staff-less housing-management GmbH, indirectly held all of S-GmbH, a group service and financing company. From 2008 S-GmbH rented roofs from the plaintiff and third parties, built 23 plants, 14 on the plaintiff's roofs, and fed power for remuneration from 2009. Solar was 0.38 percent of turnover in 2009 and 0.71 percent in 2010. Use was free, then 1 euro per sqm yearly from 2009. The plaintiff, parent of W-GmbH which was parent of S-GmbH, claimed the extended reduction for 2008 to 2010; after audit only the simple reduction under § 9 Nr. 1 Satz 1 GewStG was allowedBundesfinanzhof.
The extended reduction rewards companies that only manage own propertyBundesfinanzhof. It is lost where the owner earns original business income through a split by leasing essential assets and sharing the operator's value creation.
A split needs personal and factual entanglementBundesfinanzhof. A 100 percent indirect holding sufficed for personal entanglement
Bundesfinanzhof. Factual entanglement needs an essential asset, judged from the operator's view by functional weight for the whole enterprise, with turnover ratios as an indicator
Bundesfinanzhof.
Purely obligatory rights can qualify because Wirtschaftsgut is broad. Essentiality failed hereBundesfinanzhof. S-GmbH worked almost entirely in housing management
Bundesfinanzhof; solar was a small add-on with no link to its core
Bundesfinanzhof, under 1 percent of turnover and irrelevant to the core. The shop-branch case law on location-based essentiality does not transfer to opening a new field, and an asset essential only to a marginal segment is not enough
Bundesfinanzhof. The sideline could even have continued on third-party roofs alone. Group green interest is irrelevant.
The 2009-2010 correction is separate. Inside an Organkreis add-backs and reductions do not apply unless effects offsetBundesfinanzhof, per 18 May 2011 X R 4/10
Bundesfinanzhof. The extended reduction is denied where a property company leases all property inside the same Organkreis
Bundesfinanzhof, per X R 4/10 and 11 July 2024 III R 41/22
Bundesfinanzhof. Where only individual assets are let for consideration and the reduction otherwise holds, a correction must still prevent unjustified relief
Bundesfinanzhof. Findings were missing whether the rents paid by S-GmbH were inside the parent's extended reduction and whether § 8 Nr. 1 Buchst. e GewStG add-backs were made in the attributed income
Bundesfinanzhof. Full denial is unavailable
Bundesfinanzhof because not all property was leased inside the unity
Bundesfinanzhof.
The court also doubted the dismissal of the 2009 assessment challenge as inadmissibleBundesfinanzhof: § 35b Abs. 2 Satz 2 GewStG since 14 December 2010 may already apply because the first loss statement for 31 December 2009 appears filed in 2013.
The legal basis is § 2 Abs. 2 Satz 2, § 9 Nr. 1 Satz 1 and Satz 2 ff. and § 8 Nr. 1 Buchst. e GewStG and § 15 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 1, Abs. 2 EStG.
Check whether roof and other intra-group rents are neutralised between §8 add-backs at the subsidiary and the extended reduction at the property parent.