GermanyBundesfinanzhof
Trade-tax provision raises gain on sale of partnership interest
BFH holds that a partnership trade-tax provision proportionally reduces the exiting partner capital account and raises the disposal gain, even for the part triggered by the sale itself.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A trade-tax provision formed by a partnership reduces the capital account of a partner who sells his interestBundesfinanzhof, even where the provision was itself triggered by the sale
Bundesfinanzhof. The disposal gain is correspondingly higher.
Bundesfinanzhof
The Bundesfinanzhof so held on 8 October 2026, IV R 4/25, rejecting the seller's revisionBundesfinanzhof against the Sächsisches Finanzgericht judgment of 13 May 2024. The assessed 2017 gain of 461,905.91 euros
Bundesfinanzhof stands.
Bundesfinanzhof
The plaintiff, a GmbH, held 19 percent of a trading GbRBundesfinanzhof and sold to D-GmbH effective at the expiry of 31 December 2017
Bundesfinanzhof, with results from then due to the buyer. The price was 476,380.33 euros.
Bundesfinanzhof The partnership had formed a 68,166 euro trade-tax provision for 2017.
Bundesfinanzhof The Finanzamt cut the plaintiff's account by its 19 percent share
Bundesfinanzhof, 12,951.54 euros
Bundesfinanzhof, to 14,474.42 euros
Bundesfinanzhof, yielding the gain, and attributed a 19 percent trade-tax base share. The plaintiff sought 448,954.37 euros without the provision share, arguing it had left before trade tax arose at period end.
The gain under § 16 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 2, Abs. 2 EStG is price minus costs over the balance-sheet value at exit, the capital account under § 4 Abs. 1 or § 5 EStG. That account must reflect all provisions to be shown at exit, including a trade-tax provision, even the part relating to the disposal gain itself under § 7 Satz 2 Nr. 2 GewStG.Bundesfinanzhof The provision therefore lowers the account and raises the gain.
Bundesfinanzhof
The court accepted the resulting tax-on-tax.Bundesfinanzhof § 7 Satz 2 Nr. 2 GewStG brings co-entrepreneur disposal gains into partnership trade income except for directly participating natural persons
Bundesfinanzhof, implying the gain arises before exit and belongs to pre-change income. The account at exit is still cut by the provision on that gain.
Bundesfinanzhof That trade tax only arises at period end under § 18 GewStG does not change this timing
Bundesfinanzhof.
Non-deductibility under § 4 Abs. 5b EStG is no defence.Bundesfinanzhof It only adds back deducted trade tax off-balance-sheet and does not alter the provision in the tax balance sheet
Bundesfinanzhof.
The 14 January 2016 judgment IV R 5/14 does not help. Its leaving-partner statements concern § 35 EStG and its typified distribution by the general profit key, not the capital-account computation for the disposal gain.
Procedurally, a court order can become final in parts. The plaintiff limited its oral-hearing request to the severable gain assessment, expressly accepting the 10 June 2026 order on the § 35 Abs. 2 EStG base-share finding. That part therefore acts as a judgment under § 90a Abs. 3 Halbsatz 1 FGO and the later re-examination request came too late. The hearing complaint failed because no other outcome was possible.
For practice, price exits assuming the seller bears his provision share through a lower account, including provision on the gain itself, and address base-share allocation expressly.
The legal basis is § 16 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 2, Abs. 2 EStG, § 7 Satz 2 Nr. 2 and § 18 GewStG, § 4 Abs. 5b and § 35 Abs. 2 EStG and §§ 90, 90a, 119 Nr. 3 FGO.
Price partnership exits assuming the seller bears his trade-tax provision share through a lower capital account, and allocate the trade-tax base share expressly.