GermanyBundesfinanzhof
Unperformed first year voids tax group with no retroactive fix
BFH denies corporate and trade-tax Organschaft for 2020 where profit-transfer agreement covering 2019 was not performed that year; shifting the term to 2020-2024 in 2023 cannot cure it.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A profit-transfer agreement that is not actually performed in the first year of its agreed five-year minimum term cannot support a corporate or trade-tax Organschaft at all.Bundesfinanzhof A later amendment that retroactively moves the start of the term under civil law does not cure the failure for tax purposes.
Bundesfinanzhof
The Bundesfinanzhof so held on 14 October 2026, I R 18/25 and I R 19/25. It set aside the Finanzgericht Berlin-Brandenburg judgments of 8 July 2025 and dismissed the 2020 claims for separate and uniform determination under § 14 Abs. 5 KStG and against the 2020 trade-tax assessment.
The case concerned a GmbH as putative subsidiary and an X-GmbH & Co. KG as putative parent. On 22 November 2019 they signed a Gewinnabführungsvertrag (GAV) providing in § 5 that it would take effect on registration and apply from 1 January 2019 for five years, to 31 December 2023. It was entered in the register in December 2019 and performed only from 1 January 2020Bundesfinanzhof. The Finanzamt denied the 2020 Organschaft. In 2022 the parties added a dynamic loss-assumption clause under § 302 AktG, and on 9 February 2023 they amended § 5 so the contract would apply only from 1 January 2020, shifting the term to 2020 to 2024.
The Finanzgericht had accepted the amended contract for 2020, seeing only a forward-looking postponement of a minimum term that already existed in the dispute year. The Bundesfinanzhof rejected that view: the original term began in 2019Bundesfinanzhof, and 2019 saw no performance at all
Bundesfinanzhof.
Recognition requires under § 14 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 3 Satz 1 KStG a GAV within the meaning of § 291 Abs. 1 AktG concluded for at least five yearsBundesfinanzhof and performed throughout its entire duration
Bundesfinanzhof. For a GmbH subsidiary § 17 Satz 1 KStG applies the same test, and § 2 Abs. 2 Satz 2 GewStG refers to §§ 14, 17 KStG for trade tax. Financial integration under § 14 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 1 Satz 1 KStG is judged for the dispute year alone, but performance is judged over the whole agreed minimum term
Bundesfinanzhof because the statute says "während seiner gesamten Geltungsdauer". Following its judgments of 2 November 2022, I R 29/19 and I R 37/19, the court treats non-performance in any minimum-term year, including the first, as a fully failed Organschaft, a so-called verunglückte Organschaft
Bundesfinanzhof.
The 2023 amendment could not repair this.Bundesfinanzhof Civil-law retroactivity does not bind tax law.
Bundesfinanzhof No statute permits retroactive cure of a complete first-year performance failure
Bundesfinanzhof; the healing rules in § 14 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 3 Satz 4 f. KStG do not cover it, and § 14 Abs. 1 Satz 2 KStG could at most operate for the year the amendment took effect, here 2023. The saving clause in § 6 GAV did not help because it presupposes invalid or impracticable provisions or a gap, while the 1 January 2019 start was expressly agreed and civilly performable.
For practice, align the contractual start with the first year in which profit will actually be transferred and loss assumed, and secure timely registration and financial integration for that year. A whole missing year is no minor slip. Review GAVs with a retroactive first year that was never performed: backdating the start will not restore the failed yearsBundesfinanzhof.
The legal basis is § 14 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 1 Satz 1 and Nr. 3 Satz 1, Abs. 5 and § 17 KStG, § 2 Abs. 2 Satz 2 GewStG and §§ 291, 302 AktG.
Align each new Gewinnabführungsvertrag start date with the first year of actual profit transfer and loss assumption, and review existing GAVs with an unperformed retroactive first year.