GermanyBundesfinanzhof
Failed CHP investment stays business loss; timing needs proof
BFH keeps futile BHKW outlay in business income and treats the switch to a lease model as a continued business, but sends the 2010 loss timing back: a Ponzi scheme alone does not prove irrecoverability that year.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A taxpayer who pays for a mobile combined heat-and-power unit (BHKW) that is never delivered because the seller runs a fraudulent Ponzi scheme still acts within business incomeBundesfinanzhof, and moving from an administration model to a lease model does not end that business
Bundesfinanzhof. But the deduction year turns on proof, not on the Ponzi label
Bundesfinanzhof.
The Bundesfinanzhof so held on 15 July 2026, X R 26/23. It agreed the futile outlay belongs to business incomeBundesfinanzhof, but set aside the Finanzgericht Sachsen-Anhalt judgment
Bundesfinanzhof of 22 August 2023 and remanded the 2010 loss-timing question
Bundesfinanzhof.
The plaintiff bought a 30 kW BHKW for 22,500 euros net in March 2010 for feed-in revenue, signed three 21-year administration contracts in April, paid in May and registered a business, but received no energy revenue under that model. In August 2010 he leased the BHKW to the seller for ten years with two five-year options for 10,800 euros net yearly, receiving about 3,600 euros for September to November. The unit was never delivered.Bundesfinanzhof Over 1,400 investors were defrauded and the operators, who never intended delivery, were convicted in 2014 of gang fraud. Distribution stopped in December 2010; insolvency opened in March 2011. The plaintiff claimed a 21,412 euro loss under § 4 Abs. 3 EStG.
Classification follows the taxpayer's view at contracting, not hindsight.Bundesfinanzhof The intended acquisition therefore produced Einkünfte aus Gewerbebetrieb
Bundesfinanzhof, as settled for this model in the 7 February 2018 judgment X R 10/16.
The August switch was a Betriebsverpachtung im Ganzen, not a Betriebsaufgabe.Bundesfinanzhof Leasing the whole business without moving assets to private wealth generally continues the business where the lease covers the business as a whole or all essential bases.
Bundesfinanzhof Cessation needs an express declaration
Bundesfinanzhof; without one the business is deemed continued
Bundesfinanzhof. It suffices that resumption by the lessor or a universal or gratuitous singular successor appears objectively possible.
Bundesfinanzhof Here the sole asset, the BHKW still to be delivered, was leased, no cessation was declared, and the ten-year term left resumption objectively possible. Fraud as the foundation and formation plus lease in the same year change nothing.
Bundesfinanzhof
Timing is stricter. Under § 4 Abs. 3 EStG outflows fall in the year paid per § 11 Abs. 2 Satz 1 EStGBundesfinanzhof, but § 4 Abs. 3 Satz 3 EStG requires following Absetzung für Abnutzung, so costs of depreciable fixed assets spread through AfA under §§ 7 ff. EStG.
Bundesfinanzhof Futile outlays that never become acquisition costs are deductible when it becomes clear there will be no AfA distribution because consideration will likely stay absent and repayment cannot be obtained.
Bundesfinanzhof Great probability suffices
Bundesfinanzhof; certainty, a final conviction or exhausted enforcement are not needed
Bundesfinanzhof. The court judges retrospectively when the taxpayer had enough indications of fraud and likely non-recovery, counting claims against the counterparty and liable third parties.
Bundesfinanzhof
There is no general rule that a Ponzi scheme always means total loss is already highly probable.Bundesfinanzhof Seized assets, entry level, administrator quota reports and the fraudster's finances are case-specific
Bundesfinanzhof, as with other insolvencies where opening alone never suffices
Bundesfinanzhof. The Finanzgericht had inferred a very high 2010 probability of total failure from the Ponzi label alone
Bundesfinanzhof, without findings on assets, the 2011 insolvency, quotas or damages
Bundesfinanzhof. A September 2026 letter about a 2026 loss notice does not decide 2010. The case returns for those findings.
Bundesfinanzhof
The legal basis is § 4 Abs. 3 and Satz 3, §§ 7 ff., § 11 Abs. 2 Satz 1, § 15 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 1, § 16 Abs. 3b and § 22 Nr. 3 EStG.Bundesfinanzhof
Document the year in which repayment failure became highly probable with administrator reports and recovery records before claiming a futile investment loss.