GermanyBundesfinanzhof
Longer contract does not save group missing its first year
BFH holds a first-year failure kills the Organschaft even where the agreed term exceeds five years and five later consecutive years were performed; an authority beBPo filing needs only a simple signature.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
Missing the first year of an agreed minimum profit-transfer term kills a corporate and trade-tax Organschaft even where the agreed term exceeds five years and the contract is then performed for five consecutive remaining years.Bundesfinanzhof An overlong term does not cure the failed first year.
Bundesfinanzhof
The Bundesfinanzhof so held on 14 October 2026, I R 18/23Bundesfinanzhof, a companion to I R 18, 19/25 decided the same day. It set aside the Finanzgericht Nürnberg judgment of 28 June 2022 and dismissed the claims for 2013 to 2017.
The case concerned a GmbH parent and its subsidiary. On 17 October 2011 they signed a Gewinnabführungsvertrag (GAV) providing that if registration occurred after 2011, the five-year minimum would run from the registration year, profit duty would shift to 1 January of that year, and first termination would be 31 December 2016 with yearly extension. The contract was registered on 3 August 2012, took effect on 1 January 2012Bundesfinanzhof, and was performed only from 1 January 2013
Bundesfinanzhof. The Finanzamt denied the körperschaft- and gewerbesteuerliche Organschaft, amending 2013-2014 assessments and revoking § 14 Abs. 5 KStG determinations for 2014 to 2017.
The Finanzgericht had allowed the group. Reading termination as shifted to 31 December 2017, it treated 2013 to 2017 as a performed five-year minimum and the missed 2012 as harmless. The Bundesfinanzhof rejected that.Bundesfinanzhof
Recognition requires under § 14 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 3 Satz 1 KStG a GAV under § 291 Abs. 1 AktG for at least five yearsBundesfinanzhof and performed throughout its entire duration
Bundesfinanzhof. For a GmbH subsidiary § 17 Satz 1 KStG applies the same test, and § 2 Abs. 2 Satz 2 GewStG refers to §§ 14, 17 KStG for trade tax. Following 10 May 2017 I R 51/15 and 2 November 2022 I R 29/19 and I R 37/19, non-performance in any minimum-term year, including the first, produces a fully failed Organschaft, a verunglückte Organschaft
Bundesfinanzhof, because the statute says "während seiner gesamten Geltungsdauer".
That uniform view defeats the overlong-term argument.Bundesfinanzhof Whether the agreed term was five years 2012 to 2016 or, on the taxpayer's reading, six years to 2017, the first agreed year 2012 saw no performance
Bundesfinanzhof, and five performed later years cannot supply it
Bundesfinanzhof. Construction of § 3 of this GAV was therefore left open. A whole missing year is again no minor slip for proportionality.
On admissibility, an authority filing through the special electronic authority mailbox (beBPo) needs no handwritten signature. Under § 52a FGO, a document on the secure path of § 52a Abs. 4 Satz 1 Nr. 3 FGO needs only a simple signature, such as a typed surname, and the holder need only be the authority the document belongs to. The 26 April 2023 grounds from the Finanzamt beBPo therefore satisfied the written form.
For practice, the agreed start controls, not the first performed yearBundesfinanzhof: here the 2012 start with performance only from 2013 failed even with five later performed years
Bundesfinanzhof. Diary registration and performance for the agreed first year. Treat existing GAVs whose first agreed year saw no performance as failed for those years. Keep the beBPo transmission record for authority filings.
The legal basis is § 14 Abs. 1 Satz 1 Nr. 3 Satz 1, Abs. 5 and § 17 KStG, § 2 Abs. 2 Satz 2 GewStG, § 291 AktG and §§ 52a, 120, 126 FGO.
Set new profit-transfer terms to start in the first year of actual performance and keep the beBPo transmission record for authority filings.