GermanyBundesfinanzhof
Fraud beside the chain does not cost buyer input VAT
The Federal Fiscal Court requires evasion at a prior or later stage of the same chain, not sham invoices alongside it.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
Input VAT cannot be denied merely because the supplier evaded tax alongside the supply chain.Bundesfinanzhof The Federal Fiscal Court held in V R 31/25
Bundesfinanzhof of 16 July 2026
Bundesfinanzhof that the Court of Justice case law on fraud-tainted transactions justifies refusal only where the evasion concerns a prior or subsequent stage of the same supply chain
Bundesfinanzhof, set aside the Münster Fiscal Court judgment
Bundesfinanzhof and remanded the precious-metals case
Bundesfinanzhof.
The dispute concerns 2012 precious-metals supplies by A-GmbH to B-GmbH under credit notes. A-GmbH's books recorded purchases from X-GmbH and Y-GmbH, which filed no VAT returns for the year. A-GmbH claimed their invoiced tax in the same advance returns reporting the onward supplies, and B-GmbH claimed the tax charged by A-GmbH. A-GmbH's manager was convicted of evasion for cutting the liability with sham-invoice input tax knowing X and Y had not supplied the metals. The office treated the chain as planned fraud and denied B-GmbH, now insolvent, the input tax. The Fiscal Court upheld that in second proceedings: the supplies were real, but B-GmbH should have known it joined an evasion-tainted transaction, invoking the Directive's anti-fraud aim although section 25f did not yet apply.
The Federal Fiscal Court held that wrong. Each transaction stands alone; upstream or downstream fraud removes the deduction only where the buyer knew or should have known from objective circumstances that the acquisition joined evasion at a prior or later stage of that chainBundesfinanzhof. The evasion must concern the same chain transactionally
Bundesfinanzhof: the same, prior or later supply went undeclared, or input tax was wrongly claimed for a prior or later supply of the same goods
Bundesfinanzhof. No comprehensive audit of the issuer's status, power to supply or return compliance is required.
On the findings that test fails. X and Y never supplied the metals at allBundesfinanzhof; they appear only as sham-invoice issuers for A-GmbH's wrongful claim. With no flow from X and Y via A to B
Bundesfinanzhof, there is evasion occasioned by the delivery, not in its chain
Bundesfinanzhof. Fungibility does not help: a supplier-created book link without objective existence cannot infect the delivery at a prior stage. The tax was claimed merely on the occasion of, not for, a prior supply of the same metals.
Unlike its 2021 case where every trader failed to file or declare, the Court left other taint open. A-to-B evasion is out given declared turnovers, but nothing was found on whether unknown actual suppliers to A evaded tax — the manager spoke only of boot-to-boot receipts from unnamed persons — or whether B's people should have known. Münster must establish that with the knowledge test.
The insolvency objection fails: with a contested assessment already open, sections 180(2) and 185 of the Insolvency Code require determination by continuing the appeal, so the section 251(3) finding was correctly a dependent part of the objection decision. Nor does the old section 25d liability rule block a founded denial, with 2024-2025 Court of Justice rulings cited; no Article 267 reference was needed.
The legal basis is section 15(1) sentence 1 point 1 with sections 25d and 25f of the Umsatzsteuergesetz and Article 168(a) of the VAT Directive 2006/112/EC, applied with sections 126(3) sentence 1 point 2 and 143(2) of the Finanzgerichtsordnung, section 251(3) of the Abgabenordnung and Article 267 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.
In fraud-exposed supply chains, test whether the evasion hit the same goods at an adjacent chain stage before conceding the deduction.