GermanyBundesfinanzhof
Late brief forces reasons for refusing to reopen hearing
The Federal Fiscal Court sets aside two judgments where the court misread a new opening-balance argument as repetition.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A court that refuses to reopen oral proceedings after a late brief must show it actually grasped the brief.Bundesfinanzhof The Federal Fiscal Court joined complaints X B 64,65/25, set aside two Nuremberg Fiscal Court judgments of 22 May 2025 and remanded the dispute over a balance-sheet correction and loan interest for rehearing
Bundesfinanzhof, using direct remand in complaint proceedings under section 116(6) of the Finanzgerichtsordnung.
The dispute concerns a hotel, 2007 loans of 2.7 million euros secured by land charge, insolvencies since 2010, a 2011 UK discharge, a renewed business split from 2015 with 3.0 million booked in the opening balance rising to 3.7 million at end-2018 with 210,000 euros of interest, and continuation by the heir after the 2017 death. The office disallowed the 2018 interest, then dissolved the full 3.7 million with profit effect, arguing unenforceability since 2011 and correction in the first open year regardless of operator change. At the 22 May 2025 hearing counsel showed a 2019 land-charge discharge for 1.6 million refinanced elsewhere; the minutes record discussion but no guidance on which error with what profit effect was at stake. The 25 May 2025 brief argued the 2015 opening entry was profit-neutral and so must be its 2018 correction. The Fiscal Court declined reopening as repetition, dissolved the liability with profit effect while recognising a 1.6 million land-charge provision, and denied the interest for lack of proof.
The Federal Fiscal Court held the refusal discretionaryBundesfinanzhof but defective
Bundesfinanzhof. Reopening under section 93(3) sentence 2 is discretionary, decided on the court's own motion even without application, with reasons stated for review. A discretionary error is a procedural error under section 115(2) point 3 and a hearing violation under section 119 point 3, including reasoning on a wrong factual basis, since the brief's content is part of that basis. The court missed the brief's core
Bundesfinanzhof — whether a profit-neutral opening entry must be corrected profit-neutrally
Bundesfinanzhof — which appeared in no earlier pleading, was not minuted as raised orally, and drew no engagement in the judgment. Calling it repetition cannot carry the refusal.
Bundesfinanzhof The decision could rest on the error.
Bundesfinanzhof
Substantively the Court endorsed the complainant's reading while leaving divergence open. The 2015 booking error is corrected where it still stands in the first open year, but opening entries are profit-neutral and must be corrected profit-neutrally by breaking continuity in the 1 January 2018 opening balance; only 2018 liabilities resting on profit-effective 2015-2017 bookings are corrected with profit effect. The 2011 route is closed: with only rental income and no 2011 balance, a missed cessation gain cannot be fixed by correction.
Interest deductibility stays open. No findings exist on whether, how much and for what purpose payments were made. If payments averted enforcement from the hotel land charge to preserve the income-earning use of business property, the remand must test business cause under section 4(4), the Court noted with its March 2026 partnership-enforcement case.
The legal basis is sections 93(3) sentence 2, 115(2) points 2 and 3, 116(5) and (6) and 119 point 3 of the Finanzgerichtsordnung with sections 155 sentence 1 and 160(2) and 165 of the Zivilprozessordnung, and sections 4(1), 4(4), 5(1) sentence 1, 3a(5), 16(3) and 16(3b) of the Einkommensteuergesetz.
After the hearing, file any new profit-neutrality argument promptly and pinpoint what the minutes omit about the court's guidance.