GermanyBundesfinanzhof
No input VAT on estimated expenses without full VAT test
The Federal Fiscal Court reverses a Hessian ruling that granted input tax up to estimated income-tax expenses and sends a motorsport sponsorship case back.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
Input VAT claimed on expenses the tax office recognised only as estimated income-tax deductions must still pass the full VAT testBundesfinanzhof. The Federal Fiscal Court held that granting input tax on merely income-tax-estimated operating expenses without examining section 15(1) sentence 1 point 1 of the Umsatzsteuergesetz is unlawful
Bundesfinanzhof, set aside the Hessian Fiscal Court judgment
Bundesfinanzhof of 19 April 2024 and remanded the case
Bundesfinanzhof.
The claimant, a GbR founded in 2010 running a marketing and events agency, reported advertising and organisation services for partner-linked companies and sponsors connected to a joint practice, plus motorsport marketing in a racing series. Investigators found 88% of receipts came from partner-linked entities and much claimed input tax rested on sports cars and a luxury car used exclusively privately, race cars with clinic and sponsor livery, and a race-capable sports car bought in July 2011 and resold in August 2011 without road registration. The office treated the exclusively privately used sports cars and luxury car as non-deductible private expenditure and disputed the motorsport-related input tax.
The Fiscal Court had granted input tax up to the office's estimated income-tax expense figureBundesfinanzhof, treating taxable sponsoring supplies and invoices as established. The Federal Fiscal Court held that legally flawed
Bundesfinanzhof. The claimant bears the burden for every supporting fact: supply by another entrepreneur for its enterprise, use for taxed transactions with a direct and immediate link or for the overall economic activity, and an invoice meeting sections 14 and 14a
Bundesfinanzhof. An estimate cannot replace those findings
Bundesfinanzhof, and income-tax recognition of estimated expenses says nothing for VAT
Bundesfinanzhof. Capping the claim at the estimated figure could not cure the missing findings, and the filed invoice schedule far exceeded the amounts claimed. Further relief is possible only beyond input tax already allowed.
The claimant's appeal on the July 2011 car also won a rehearingBundesfinanzhof. The lower court had refused allocation to the business and alternatively applied the representation bar, reasoning from the partners' preference for high-value sports cars, ownership of several such cars, B's driving participation and missing road registration. The Federal Fiscal Court held the one-month buy-and-resell, the asserted plan to resell quickly at a profit without racing or private use, and possible active dealer-like distribution steps had not been weighed. Mere acquisition and resale for a sales profit is no sustainable-revenue use, while active marketing can be an economic activity regardless of transaction numbers; all circumstances of dual-use goods must be examined.
For the rehearing the Court added non-binding guidance. Mere race participation is no economic activity, but sponsor performance through logos and series participation, so far as attributable to the claimant rather than the clinic owning the team, could belong to its enterprise. Motorsport inputs could then be deductible in principle yet still barred by section 15(1a) with section 4(5) sentence 1 point 4 and sentence 2 of the Einkommensteuergesetz, with onward supply of affected goods exempt under section 4 point 28. The claimant must now list each input in ordered form with its enterprise link and taxed use; the court need not extract that from a 1,500-page bundle and may then sample.
The legal basis is section 15(1) sentence 1 point 1 and section 15(1a) of the Umsatzsteuergesetz with sections 14 and 4 point 28, section 4(5) sentence 1 point 4 and sentence 2 of the Einkommensteuergesetz and Articles 168(a) and 9(1) of the VAT Directive 2006/112/EC, applied through sections 76, 118 and 126 of the Finanzgerichtsordnung.
For similar sponsorship and vehicle-cost files, tie each claimed input item to a specific invoice and taxed use instead of relying on estimated expense totals.