GermanyBundesfinanzhof
Partnership notices bind all partners once served on named agent
The Federal Fiscal Court holds internal mandate defects irrelevant where a tax professional is named in the return, and a misnamed partner is fixed by interpretation.
By Taxxa AI OyPublished 19 November 2026
Industry: Across industries
A partnership assessment notice served on the tax professional named as joint authorised recipient in the partnership return binds every partner named in that return, even if the internal mandate was defective.Bundesfinanzhof The Federal Fiscal Court dismissed the revision in IV R 3/24 of 3 September 2026 and held that assessment notices for 2004 and 2005 served in March 2011 on the XY-Treuhand auditing firm
Bundesfinanzhof
Bundesfinanzhof had already become effective against the claimant and final
Bundesfinanzhof
Bundesfinanzhof, so the September 2018 re-service had no legal significance
Bundesfinanzhof.
The claimant, a minority limited partner in the H-GmbH & Co. KG, objected only in April 2013Bundesfinanzhof to amended 2 and 14 March 2011 notices attributing a 3,884,296.25 euro disposal gain and current income to it. It said it never mandated the recipient and learned of the notices only through follow-on assessments. The Cologne court had treated March 2011 service as ineffective
Bundesfinanzhof, September 2018 service as decisive
Bundesfinanzhof, and limitation and correction points as relevant. The Federal Fiscal Court held that reasoning wrong
Bundesfinanzhof but the dismissal correct
Bundesfinanzhof.
Naming a member of the tax advisory professions as jointly appointed authorised recipient in the Feststellungserklärung creates a presumption, the Court recalled, that every partner named in the return properly mandated that person internally.Bundesfinanzhof Appointment needs no form
Bundesfinanzhof and naming in the return suffices
Bundesfinanzhof. Internal defects are then externally irrelevant
Bundesfinanzhof: a tax professional knows what a section 183 mandate means, and verification of every mandate would defeat simplification. The mandate persists until a revocation reaches the office.
Bundesfinanzhof
The naming here required interpretation by the facts court under the recipient horizonBundesfinanzhof, applying sections 133 and 157 of the Civil Code
Bundesfinanzhof. The returns listed a P-KG limited partner with a 252 euro capital share, while only the claimant held exactly that share in the H-KG; naming the partnership itself under its pre-2004 name as its own partner was implausible; and a same-day fax from the firm computing the disposal gain for the claimant made objectively clear that the claimant was meant
Bundesfinanzhof and only the similar-sounding former name had slipped in. The signature box statement that the named recipient was appointed by all partners supports treating the external declaration as effective for every partner named, not as a mere report of an internal act
Bundesfinanzhof. No revocation had reached the office before March 2011.
Bundesfinanzhof
The March 2011 notices were also not void against the claimant.Bundesfinanzhof The claimant was clearly designated as content addressee
Bundesfinanzhof with amounts stated. The co-named PR entity, by contrast, was designated without legal-form suffix, with a contradictory office and fragmentary tax number and no evidence of any holding, so those notices were partially void as to PR
Bundesfinanzhof. Partial nullity does not void the whole where the office would have issued the notice to the correctly named addressees without the void part
Bundesfinanzhof, the Court held under section 125(4)
Bundesfinanzhof. Because the claimant objected only in April 2013, long after the one-month period
Bundesfinanzhof, the notices had become formally final
Bundesfinanzhof and bind even if unlawful
Bundesfinanzhof, including on correction and limitation points
Bundesfinanzhof
Bundesfinanzhof. The September 2018 repeat service therefore changed nothing
Bundesfinanzhof, and no forfeiture question arose.
The legal basis is sections 183(1) sentences 1 and 5 in the version applicable to the dispute years with sections 119, 124, 125, 179, 182, 181, 169, 129, 164 and 355 of the Abgabenordnung, sections 180(1) sentence 1 point 2(a) and 15a(4) of the relevant assessment provisions, and sections 40, 44, 47, 68 and 126(4) of the Finanzgerichtsordnung, with interpretation under sections 133 and 157 of the Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch.
Before challenging service, check who the partnership return names as joint authorised recipient and whether any revocation reached the tax office in time.